Modes Of Protest
Published November 16, 2004
The attempt at self-immolation in front of the White House by an alleged FBI terrorist informer is a sign of frustration and protest. Gruesome as it is, self-immolation as a mode of protest is not new, and is intended as the ultimate sacrifice, in a manner not intended to hurt anyone else. While it comes nowhere near the powerful anti-violent protests pioneered by Mahatma Gandhi and later Martin Luther King, self-immolation has been used as a means of protest by Liu Chunling in Tiananmen Square in 2001, proponents of affirmative action in India, farmers, bicyclists in San Francisco and many other recent incidents in Europe & the United States.
A psychosocial study of self-immolation of 22 college students in India found that
All subjects except one were free of manifest psychopathology. The group as a whole had a high score on Pierce's Suicide Intent Scale and displayed internal locus of control orientation. Most were ambitious, aggressive, hostile and felt alienated. The absence of manifest psychopathology sets this group apart from cases of deliberate self-harm arising in the context of psychiatric morbidity. Thwarted ambitions, a sense of alienation and intropunitive hostility can lead to protest which at times becomes altruistic and results in self-immolation.
in 1963,David Halberstam, an American journalist, witnessed the self-immolation of Thich Quang Duc in protest against the dictatorship of President Ngo Dinh Diem, who had persistently favoured the country's Catholic minority. This form of protest oftentimes sees expression in the form of hunger strikes. The fast-unto-death is a favorite mode of protest, normally broken conveniently before it is too late.
One commonality between all the examples cited is that it is the reaction of an individual to absolutism & the State, on a stage where one actor towers over the rest, and there is a sense of frustration in society. It is often considered an action of the 'infantile left', although it is more a personal action that has no label. The most recent example may or may not turn out to fit the pattern.
What could be worse is that this incident might signal an underlying frustration, resentment and mute protest within Western society
- Modes Of Protest
- Published: November 16, 2004
- Type:
- Section: Politics
- Writer: Aaman Lamba
- Aaman Lamba's BC Writer page
- Aaman Lamba's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
The intention was not to find fault or otherwise with the person involved, but more a look at the form of protest adopted. It is after all, a protest of sorts.
Since one does not have insight into the individual's personal history, I shall refrain from any comment on this individual.
Aaman, the glaring problem with self-immolation is that it is too easily dismissed as the behavior of an insane person. I believe most thoughtful people know that sane people commit suicide for rational reasons. But, I am skeptical of the public accepting self-immolation as possibly reasonable because it is vividly violent -- unlike an overdose of pain medication.
Marc, must you always deride people whenever they aren't white? You seem to be utterly convinced that most of people in the world are children of a lesser God based on the color of their skins. The man has as much right to decent treatment in America as you do. Your determination to dehumanize him is pathetic.
Anonymous blogger Mac Diva: Strong supporter of suicidal Yemenis...







What could be worse is that this incident might signal an underlying frustration, resentment and mute protest within Western society.
And of course the fact that this fruitcake wasn't (being of Yemeni heritage) a part of "Western society" doesn't enter into your equation.
And maybe you can explain how after being provided at least $100,000 by the FBI for his "services" less than two years ago he is crying poor and claims he can't provide care for his cancer stricken wife.
Oh, and while your at it, explain how a dead husband, or in this case extremly incapacitated, can provide for the same ill wife.