The undeserving veterans
Published November 12, 2004
All veterans are not equally deserving of being honored. That seems pretty clear to me, especially when the veterans at issue fought against United States. But, the managing editor of a small town newspaper in North Carolina says she doesn't get it. Lee Raynor was surprised to be button-holed by an African-American veteran and told that he was offended by a local performance that honored Confederate soldiers. The man attended a musical memorial called "Salute! A Tribute to America's Veterans" in Kinston. Raynor wrote about her confusion in The Free Press.
Near the end of the program talented T.W. Rogers sang "An American Trilogy." The hauntingly beautiful piece, recorded by Elvis Presley, is a medley of "Dixie," "The Battle Hymn of the Republic" and "Hush, Little Baby." It's both poignant and rousing. The familiar words of "Dixie" and the melancholy words whispering "You know your daddy's going to die," are followed by the rousing, "Glory, glory hallelujah."
What few people noticed, and even fewer people heard, was the outrage of a highly-decorated retired Army lieutenant colonel, a man who pulled duty in Vietnam and who has, for years, worked hard in this community.
Joe Tyson was infuriated by the song.
"It was out of the context of what they were doing," Tyson, who is black, told me later. "It was out of place. Why didn't they just wave the Confederate flag?"
Images of hoods and hangings and slavery ran through Tyson's head as Rogers sang.
"I don't expect you to understand," he said. "I almost got up and walked out, but I realized that was unprofessional."
Instead, Tyson and his wife found Salute Chairman Herman McLawhorn and Pride of Kinston Director B.J. Murphy and expressed their feelings - vehemently. Tyson has not complained to anyone else, he said, and has not discussed the incident with anyone except me.
Tyson has worked with the Salute committee since the event began. He's supported it in all areas of the community - black and white. But he won't do it again, he said. He's washing his hands of Salute.
page 1 | 2
- The undeserving veterans
- Published: November 12, 2004
- Type:
- Section: Culture
- Writer: Mac Diva
- Mac Diva's BC Writer page
- Mac Diva's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
Can't argue. I doubt I'd agree with Mac on whether Confederate soldiers should be honored generally, but by definition they were not U.S. soldiers in that war. And moreover, Veterans Day (too often it and Memorial Day are mingled in meaning) is intended to honor living veterans, so also by definition Civil War soldiers wouldn't qualify.
One thing I found interesting at the Atlanta Veterans Day parade yesterday was the contingent of ARVN (Army of the Republic of Vietnam) soldiers marching. There's apparently a Georgia chapter. Sure, honoring the actions of South Vietnamese soldiers is a good thing, but in the U.S. Veterans Day parade?
I had very mixed emotions when I saw a war memorial with a long list of names in a church in Seefeld, Austria.
Almost identical in form to the memorials you see in just about every church in Britain.
The dates were from World War II
I agree, confederate ancestors should not be honored with US ancestors. They deserve their own holiday in the South. And since Memorial Day was originally a confederate tradition, I believe that day should be reserved solely to HONOR Confederate dead for giving the "last full measure" to defend the Southland against the Northern invaders and thier illegal war.
I agree, James, with the exception of the word "solely". Memorial Day is an appropriate time to honor our dead ancestors, whether they were US soldiers, RSA soldiers, non-combatants or foreign citizens.
Veterans Day, as Cap'n Ken pointed out, should be a time to honor the US Veterans still among us.




I agree with you on this one: a whole different category entirely. In the interest of reconciliation, there is a long tradition of honoring the former enemy, but not at the same time or in the same way as those who have fought FOR you and not AGAINST you.