CD Review: Sharon Edry, Semi Broken Heart

Written by Jon Sobel
Published November 04, 2004

So much confessional folk-pop is so bad that it's one of my least favorite styles of music. That makes the occasional happy surprise all the nicer. Yes, Sharon Edry's debut CD is all about "me, me, me," and yes, the lyrics are prosy, but it has lovely arrangements and lilting, catchy tunes that - much like the wrinkle-be-gone my wife keeps trying to smear on my face - can cover those unsightly flaws: in this case, cliched themes that in a weaker setting would be just too tiresome to bear.

Edry's captivating vocals set the perfect tone of controlled passion. She complains a lot, but the way she wears her heart on her sleeve - and in her voice - has an appealing charm and sweetness. Confessional lyrics often lack poetry, and Edry's are no exception; for every evocative metaphor ("Deep in my eyes sometimes the color brown/Will turn to black") there are a couple of clumsy or watery ones ("I wear a smile like a bright white shirt that never fades to gray," "am I drowning in a million drops of pain?"). But there aren't a lot of metaphors to begin with, and anyway the music usually rises above this flaw.

"Happy Ever After" would sound perfect as the theme to a network teen drama (note to cynics: that's not meant as an insult! quite the opposite). In the beautifully arranged "Blue Rain," Edry's delicate voice sweeps over the atmopheric accompanying tracks in a somber plaint of disappointment and depression. It's one of the best examples of the great care and musicality that have gone into arranging and producing these songs. Edry, co-producer Carolann Solebello, and their musicians did a beautiful job creating sounds and moods throughout the CD. Who needs metaphors and word games when the very sounds of the voice and instruments make the emotional points so well?

Sometimes those aforementioned prosy lyrics jump out too starkly from the music, breaking its spell. "Uncertainty," for example, suffers from lyrical obviousness or laziness, the tendency to tell instead of show. But "Everything" and "Change," though also abstractions, have catchy choruses that demonstrate Edry's talent for the hook and make them hard to resist.

"Stained Glass Window" is too treacly for me, and a few numbers, like "Never-Ending Skyline" and "Possibility," are more recitatives than songs; they fail to hold this reviewer's interest. But the second half of the CD is elevated by "More Than" which shows Edry at her subtlest and most powerful, and by "The Simple Song" in which she finally banishes the bastard who seems to have given her the incentive to write all these songs in the first place.

This is a simple song

To say that you were wrong

Too bad it took so long

Add it all up and you have a CD with many high points, more good songs than most CDs by much more famous artists, and a gorgeous sound. Its best tracks, like "Happy Ever After" and "Blue Rain," are earning a place in my iTunes library. Let's hope Sharon Edry finds another evil muse - or something equally inspiring - for her next project.

Available at CD Baby

Jon Sobel is Blogcritics' theater editor, reviews NYC theater frequently, and writes a regular round-up of independent music releases. He is also a computer professional, musician, and small-time concert promoter in New York City. (His original band, Whisperado, can be blogcriticized at will, and you can also find him playing bass and singing in the Kings County Blues Band.)
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
CD Review: Sharon Edry, Semi Broken Heart
Published: November 04, 2004
Type:
Section: Music
Filed Under: Music: Folk, Music: Pop
Writer: Jon Sobel
Jon Sobel's BC Writer page
Jon Sobel's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Jon Sobel
Music: Folk
Music: Pop
All Music Articles
Jon Sobel's personal weblog
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — November 21, 2004 @ 11:46AM — Temple Stark [URL]

Jon,

I have added your review to the Advance.net network. Thank you for the post. A good vocabulary displayed. A good rythmn to the writing.

One of those pages is here.

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/21860)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments