Is it 1948 All Over Again

Written by Tom Donelson
Published October 29, 2004

In 1948, Harry S. Truman was a considerable underdog. The previous congressional election saw Republicans taking over the Congress and now Truman appeared besieged. Within his own party, many Southern Democrats left the party due to Truman support for integration and his policy of containing the Soviet Empire split a portion of the Democratic left from the rest of the Party. His domestic agenda that including socializing medical care in the United States along the lines of Great Britain health care alarmed many Republicans and Republican candidate Thomas Dewey appeared on the way to Presidency.

America was undergoing changes both domestically and in foreign affairs. Europe was in shambles and communist insurgency threatened Greece. There were large-scale communist movements that threatened many of the Western European democracy.

As for America, a new middle class appeared and many Americans moved to suburbs as demographic changes occurred. American essentially disarmed after World War II as millions of former GI tried to fit in the new economy and the economy strained to provide jobs for all of the returning combat veterans.

As for Truman, he was forced to make changes on the lam as nothing prepared him or America for the post war era. After the First World War, America came home from Europe and stayed home. Truman had to break America of Isolationist tendency for America was the lone obstacles to the Soviet Empire.

In 1946, Winston Churchill declared an iron curtain had descended across Europe and many in the Truman administration were more shocked than approving of his speech. What Churchill did was to shake America into the reality that a new World has occurred and that new world included a rival in the Soviet Empire.

In 1947, Truman created the Truman Doctrine in which he sent aid to the Greeks to keep that nation from slipping behind the Iron Curtain and in 1948; Czechoslovakia did slip behind the Iron Curtain. The Marshall Plan was designed to strengthen Europe economy and reduce communist influence in Western Europe. Europe stood on a tightrope and there was no guarantee that whole enterprise would end favorably. I interviewed a German born economists a few years about Europe post war and he told me that the German miracle began when German officials removed wage and price controls placed upon their economy by the American planners. This event occurred three years after the end of World War II. Let us say, there was plenty of mistakes made by the Truman administration.

Much of the opposition to Truman came because Truman was a plain speaking man who were making historical change that ran counter to past American previous past.

page 1 | 2
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Buy from Amazon.com
Truman Truman
David McCullough
Book,

Is it 1948 All Over Again
Published: October 29, 2004
Type:
Section: Politics
Writer: Tom Donelson
Tom Donelson's BC Writer page
Tom Donelson's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Tom Donelson
All Politics Articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — October 29, 2004 @ 22:28PM — Hal Pawluk [URL]

The "ownership society" is simply a pitch to redistribute more money into the hands of the welathy. That applies to Social Security and Health Savings Plans.

Here's some additional reading (links open in new windows):

10/18/04: The "Privatization" Rip-off: A Bush Collaboration

09/23/04: Bush's "Ownership" Scam - Part II

08/30/04: Scam Alert: Watch Out For "Ownership Society" And "Investor Class"

08/10/04: Bush's New Ad Theme: Give Us Your Money

#2 — October 29, 2004 @ 22:45PM — Brave Kelso

That's a very good piece, running against the conventional wisdom. I don't know if I agree. It may take a few years for the dust to settle.

The conventional wisdom has the present Republican candidate as a stubborn dimwit from Texas. The conventional wisdom in 1948 had Truman as a dim retail salesman from Missouri. Truman had a moral vision and integrity that prevailed in the election and he has been appreciated by later generations for the same qualities. That was implied in your post.

Your (I'm from Canada) president is not as dumb as liberals in your media (I don's say your liberal media) make him out to be) and he has been consistent and predictable. He has also been too loyal to the extremists, flacks and ideologues around him, too defensive about his values, too tied up with polls and pols to be compared to Truman.

The guy like Truman was Reagan. Love him or hate him, he was clear about where he stood and lucky. Where would Reagan's East European policy have been without Pope John Paul getting Solidarity and Poland to face down the Russians? Where would the Poles have been without Reagan and the American tanks in West Germany. An amazing era, and an amazing change in the world.

I see candidate Bush as an imitator of President Reagan in a different world. He isn't like Truman or Reagan.

#3 — October 30, 2004 @ 00:03AM — RJ [URL]

Great post! But please add an Amazon link (for Eric)...

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/21619)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments