Honesty in Art Criticism
Published September 03, 2004
Thus we can always see critical hypochrisy or all the sheeps lining up to follow the lead. Another perfect example of that theory was the orgy of great reviews by super cool contemporary art critics for The Quilt's of Gee's Bend. The New York Times dubbed this show one of the "ten most important shows in the world," and art critics who one would imagine would rather have their eyes poked out with a blunt butter knife than hang a quilt as "art" in their post-modernist flats all lined up to applaud the show.
I did too. I was enthralled and seduced not just by the quilts, but mostly by the quilters that I met.
And I went back and re-read a lot of the reviews and I was (and still) nagged by the impression that a lot of the words were written not out of honesty, but out of political correctness; it would have been suicidal for any writer, not just an art critic, to dislike the show.
I could be wrong.
But when the world's most influential daily anoints a show as one of the "ten most important shows in the world," it essentially dares every other secondary art critic in the world to disagree with them.
But I could be wrong, and because I have never been particularly fond of quilts as "fine art," I went to see this show prepared to dislike it - my own prejudice and (like Michael says) "conditioning," and a fun opportunity to disagree with the mainstream critic media.
And yet, let me repeat myself: I was enthralled and seduced not just by the quilts, but mostly by the quilters. I ended up loving the quilts because of the quilters.
And to this day I am nagged by the feeling that it was the quilters, more than the quilts, that we all liked so much.
And thus, I applaud honesty like O'Sullivan's in today's review.
- Honesty in Art Criticism
- Published: September 03, 2004
- Type:
- Section: Culture
- Writer: Lenny Campello
- Lenny Campello's BC Writer page
- Lenny Campello's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
BTW: Sothebys calling anybody anything is a joke.
They're criminals; everything they say and do is suspect.
Have a nice day,
S
Uh oh. Forced to agree with the frother. The underside of Sotheby's revealed during the trials (it is all about the money, stupid) told me what I needed to know.
And, please fix that long blue, underlined section in the blockquote. It is irritating to the eye. BTW, blue type is for links.





re: Gee's Bend -
Take away the 'quilters' and those are still some of the most fantastic images in 'contemporary' art.
Paul Klee would have been proud.
(Speaking of Klee, if he were alive, he could probably sue Richter for copyright infringement.
Richter is highly overrated, imo.)