Honesty in Art Criticism

Written by Lenny Campello
Published September 03, 2004

This review by Michael O'Sullivan of a couple of exhibitions at The Textile Museum is a perfect example of why I think O'Sullivan is the best art critic writing for the Washington Post.

Call me plebian, but I am always delighted to read an art critic that shows his colors and his prejudices when reviewing a visual exhibition, and then has the honesty and courage to somewhat change his mind.

O'Sullivan writes:

"FULL DISCLOSURE: I don't particularly like flowers or shiny metallic thread.

Which makes my recent visit to the Textile Museum to check out two exhibitions — the new "Floral Perspectives in Carpet Design" (whose title pretty much says it all) and the about-to-close "By Hand in the Electronic Age: Contemporary Tapestry" (a show with more than its share of fiber bling-bling) — potentially problematic.

See, I've been conditioned by exposure to contemporary art to mistrust the decorative. Floral art — unless it's a stand-in for sex or death, as it so often is — is not my cup of tea. And glints of gold thread woven through textiles remind me, I'm sorry to say, of Liberace.

So I was heartened, not to mention somewhat surprised, by the fact that in addition to flowers and lamé, there's something to chew on in both shows."

I'll admit that althought I liked O'Sullivan's review, I'd rather still rather watch an ice cube melt than go see "Floral Perspectives in Carpet Design," which makes O'Sullivan a more open-minded and fair critic that I can ever hope to be; but that's just me.

But I digress. My point is that it is rare to see these sort of "full disclosures" when discussing an opinion in an art review. More often than not what we find is cynicism, and writing that is what the author thinks the other "cool" critics and "hot" curators would want to read.

That also explains why a lot of contemporary art critics and curators have such dislike of painting. They have been conditioned to think that it's not cool to like painting, and it's fun to see them scramble to line up when an unexpected painter bolts out of the blue, such as Gerhard Richter and the same people who shout that "painting is dead" line up to applaud a painter who Sotheby's calls the "most influential artist in the world." Not painter, but artist.

page 1 | 2
F. Lennox Campello is a widely published Washington, DC and Philadelphia based art critic, as well as an award winning artist and curator. He is also often heard on NPR and the Voice of America discussing visual art issues. Campello also reports on Mid Atlantic area art news for the TV show ArtsMedia News.
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Honesty in Art Criticism
Published: September 03, 2004
Type:
Section: Culture
Writer: Lenny Campello
Lenny Campello's BC Writer page
Lenny Campello's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Lenny Campello
All Culture Articles
Lenny Campello's personal weblog
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — September 4, 2004 @ 10:33AM — Shark

re: Gee's Bend -

Take away the 'quilters' and those are still some of the most fantastic images in 'contemporary' art.

Paul Klee would have been proud.

(Speaking of Klee, if he were alive, he could probably sue Richter for copyright infringement.

Richter is highly overrated, imo.)

#2 — September 4, 2004 @ 10:37AM — Shark

BTW: Sothebys calling anybody anything is a joke.

They're criminals; everything they say and do is suspect.

Have a nice day,
S

#3 — September 4, 2004 @ 16:40PM — Mac Diva [URL]

Uh oh. Forced to agree with the frother. The underside of Sotheby's revealed during the trials (it is all about the money, stupid) told me what I needed to know.

And, please fix that long blue, underlined section in the blockquote. It is irritating to the eye. BTW, blue type is for links.

#4 — September 4, 2004 @ 17:16PM — Lenny [URL]

The quote is a link!

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/19428)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments