Sunni/Shiite Primer

Written by Eric Olsen
Published August 14, 2004

Though all discussion of the Middle East, Islam, Iraq, the current military action in Najaf, and seemingly the future of the world, involves discussion of the Shiah and the Sunni branches of Islam. But how many actually know what the differences between the sects are and what they mean? I, for one, did not. Reza Aslan provides a very fine, brief primer:

    one must begin not with Ali's tomb in Najaf, but
    with the barren plain of Karbala, where Ali's son, Husayn, along with most
    of the Prophet Muhammad's family, were brutally massacred in the year 680 by
    the forces of the Syrian Caliph, Yazid I.

    When Ali died, the caliphate, or leadership of the Muslim community, had
    passed to the governor of Syria, a man named Muawiyah, in a complicated
    power-sharing agreement that ensured the title would once again belong to
    the family of the Prophet upon Muawiyah's demise. However, after having
    transformed Muhammad's small community of faith into a dominant, rapidly
    expanding, and ethnically Arab kingdom of enormous wealth and power,
    Muawiyah had no intention of relinquishing his rule to a small band of
    religious purists living in the distant Arabian Peninsula. He therefore
    named his son Yazid heir to his throne.

    To those who believed that the leadership of the Muslim community should
    have never left the Prophet's family in the first place, this was an
    intolerably impious act. Throughout the Empire, but particularly in the
    volatile regions of Iraq and Iran, a massive contingent of mostly non-Arab
    Muslims calling themselves the Shiatu Ali ("the Partisans of Ali") rose up
    in revolt. The partisans sent a message to Ali's eldest surviving son,
    Husayn, to come to Kufa, the center of the rebellion in Iraq, to lead them
    in battle against the evil usurper, Yazid.

    Husayn agreed and prepared his family to march from their home in Medina to
    Kufa. They never made it. Having already crushed the Kufan rebellion,
    Yazid's army intercepted Husayn and his entourage at Karbala and, over a
    period of 10 days, massacred nearly every last member of the Prophet
    Muhammad's family.

    The events at Karbala split the Muslim community into two major factions:
    those who considered Yazid the legitimate caliph, and those who believed
    that the rightful heirs to the Prophet's mantle had been unjustly removed
    from power. Yet while Karbala signaled the end of the political aspirations
    of the Shiatu Ali and the beginning of the world's first Muslim empire,
    there was a far greater significance to the events than anyone could have
    imagined at the time.

    Four years after the massacre, a handful of the Shiatu Ali in Kufa gathered
    secretly at Karbala, not only to mourn the death of Husayn but also to atone
    for their failure to aid him at his hour of need. This concept of
    lamentation as penance was an unprecedented phenomenon in Islam. Indeed, as
    more and more partisans began gathering at Karbala, the Shiatu Ali gradually
    transformed from a failed political faction who aimed to restore leadership
    to the Prophet's family into a wholly new religious sect-Shiism, a religion
    founded on the model of the righteous believer who, like Husayn, willingly
    sacrifices himself in the struggle for justice against tyranny and
    oppression.

    page 1 | 2 | 3
Career media professional Eric Olsen is honored to be the founder and publisher of Blogcritics.org, which, quite frankly, rules - as do his wife and four children.
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Sunni/Shiite Primer
Published: August 14, 2004
Type:
Section: Politics
Writer: Eric Olsen
Eric Olsen's BC Writer page
Eric Olsen's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Eric Olsen
All Politics Articles
Eric Olsen's personal weblog
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — September 5, 2004 @ 23:23PM — BJ

I have read a lot about the historical sources of the rift between Sunnis and Shi'ahs. But is there a manner of dress or other visual method of distinguishing the two? With both sects living side by side in countries such as Iraq, how do the members of each sect tell who they should hate?

#2 — September 6, 2004 @ 05:02AM — SFC SKI

First of all, the Shi'a and Sunni are not running through the streets killing each other, especially in Baghdad, but in other cities throughout Iraq as well.

There is no hard and fast rule to distinguish the two sects. IN fact, it makes it harder in some ways to find insurgents, though the ones with the long scraggly beards are usually Wahabi Sunni or hard line Shia. MOst Iraqi men do not grow beards until they are in their late 50's or so.

Mostly, they now who is who by extended family lines, villages, and neighborhoods. Many Iraqis were restricted in their travels under the old regime, and so a stranger is easy to pick out to other locals.

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/18653)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments