Blogcritics: Comments on Alien vs. Predator

Comment by jon

Mon, 30 Aug 2004 01:58:39 EDT

the part where she kills an alien and gets 'marked' for her efforts is lifted out of an AvP novel from some years back. well, in that novel, at least the predators brought the female protagonist (she was asian in the book i think; japanese, if i remember correctly) to the predator homeworld where she was accepted because she had the mark of the warrior that the predator whom she fought the aliens with, had given her. come to think of it, the novel had the same premise as well: pesky humans occupying and setting up base on a planet used for the predator's hunting. oh well. was her name machinko in the novel? somehow that name comes to mind.

Comment by Tom Johnson

Fri, 13 Aug 2004 11:30:34 EDT

From what little I've read from fans of the comics and films, PWS Anderson has basically destroyed both franchises with this one - taking little bits here and there that he liked out of each one and ignoring everything else that didn't suit his needs, like the Alien lifecycle (I hear that someone gets face-hugged and minutes later a chestburster appears. It's always been an un-listed amount of time, but seemingly several days, and then the creature runs off to mature for a couple of days.) I'm a huge fan of the Alien franchise, not so much of Predator, but I think I'm holding off on this one until the DVD - especially if it'll contain extra footage.

Comment by *** Dave

Fri, 13 Aug 2004 10:36:10 EDT

I'm not only aware of it, I even make reference to it in the first paragraph. While there may very well be some very good AvP comics/novels out there, I don't believe that the impetus to produce them, or this film, was the desire to make great literature. It was more, "Predators vs Aliens -- would that be cool, or what?!" There's nothing wrong with that (or with cross-overs in general -- I particularly liked a Walt Simonson-drawn Robocop vs Terminators series, of the same ilk). One can certainly tell good stories that way. And there are elements of this film that certainly qualify -- like I said, I'm happy I went to see it, and think I'll probably pick up the DVD. But it's not a great movie, or even (IMO) a great sf/action movie. Aliens, at least, was better. That it's fair-to-good is nothing to sneeze at, esp. since I think most people are expecting less of it than that.

Comment by jadester

Fri, 13 Aug 2004 09:58:04 EDT

you do of course realise, that there is a whole series of Aliens Vs Predator novels and comics? I'm not sure if the plot of the film closely follows any of these in particular, and as you'd expect there is a fair amonut of "duds" in the group, but equally there are some pretty good stories to be had.

Comment by Eric Olsen

Fri, 13 Aug 2004 08:37:48 EDT

very fine job Dave, great to have you back, thanks!