Ask the Pros: Screenwriting
Published August 11, 2004
Nobody really knows how many screenplays are written each year. Reports are that some 40,000 scripts may be registered with the Writer's Guild West annually, which suggests many more are started and abandoned. And many have noted that nobody really wants to write the Great American Novel anymore; now everybody wants to write the Next Great Blockbuster (or "tentpole" movie, in the parlance of Hollywood). As William Goldman writes in Adventures of the Screen Trade, when he started screenwriting there were no books or format guides to consult; he had to learn simply by reading other screenplays.
That has changed. First there was Syd Field, whose books on screenwriting format brought clarity and the three act structure to the forefront. Now there are a host of screenwriting websites, magazines, books, gurus, and more, all looking to make a buck off aspiring screenwriters' hopes and dreams. Just writing a screenplay is big business anymore, and there are thousands of people looking for advice and insight into how to break into "the business." They devour Robert McKee's book on Story and they quibble on message boards over whether to bind a script with two brads or three, with every other question seeming to be: "So, do I have to move to L.A. to really hit the big time?"
Ask the Pros: Screenwriting is a fascinating little book. Not because it teaches screenwriting format, because it doesn't. If you want to read about format, there are plenty of books on the market, from the aforementioned (and ubiquitous) Story, David Trottier's Screenwriter's Bible, Denny Martin Flinn's How Not to Write a Screenplay: 101 Common Mistakes Most Screenwriters Make, and The Complete Guide to Standard Script Formats by Judith Haag and Hillis Cole. But Ask the Pros: Screenwriting does something else, something I think is exceptionally valuable for aspiring screenwriters.
It asks professionals - writers, agents, managers, producers, readers, and more - a host of "frequently asked questions," and records their answers. What I really liked about this book was the fact that on many points, there was disagreement among the professionals, or at the very least a difference of opinion about how to go about things. As an aspiring screenwriter who has bounced around the various screenwriting circles online, you frequently hear some "expert" spouting off about how there is only one way to do things. The problem is, many people end up believing that, and it isn't true; as the old saying goes, there's more than one way to skin a cat. And Ask the Pros highlights that fact.
- Ask the Pros: Screenwriting
- Published: August 11, 2004
- Type:
- Section: Books
- Filed Under: Books: Nonfiction, Books: Reference
- Writer: W.E. Wallo
- W.E. Wallo's BC Writer page
- W.E. Wallo's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
Thanks Bill, very nice review. I think the real purpose of books like this is to encourage people to pursue their dreams, which is never a high-percentage proposition, but is how the good stuff does come out.
Has anyone read a really good book on writing TV? Does one exist? If one existed, what questions should it answer?
- Alex Epstein
Author, Crafty Screenwriting
Alex -- I'd really like to know if there's a book out there that talks about television writing as well. If I ever deviated from writing novels, I'd love to give a crack at TV. Of course, from what I've heard, having a heap of connections helps a lot.
Excellent website. I have seen a lot of movies at the local theaters, tv, dvd, morpheus and other venues. I must say that the talent that hollywood possesses is tremendous.
I understand that the industry is losing some revenue due to morpheus and related software. In any event can you guys make the movies and shows that appear on TV available on the Morpheus network.




Other than "Star Wars", these 'how-to' books (Syd Field, McGee, et al) are the worst thing to happen to screenwriting since domesticated primate wannabee writers discovered Joseph Campbell.
20-something Hollowood morons with power will inevitably throw "three-act-structure" and the "page 10 rule" or some-such nonsense into every note session -- and these are the same punks whose knowledge of film history goes blank on earlier than 1990 or so.
Feh. No wonder 99% of the celluloid fecal material coming out of Hollowood looks like it was written by a committee using a 'formula': IT WAS.