Blogcritics: Comments on Review: Collateral

Comment by Mark

Wed, 22 Sep 2004 19:12:44 EDT

* What was the deal with the fox in the road ? * Was it really a big coincidence in the end or in the beginning? ie. Wasnt Vincent coming out of the same building in the beginning of the movie (with keypass and all) as the one on his final stop??

Comment by Vic

Sat, 7 Aug 2004 22:40:40 EDT

Hey man, I was just kidding. :-) Great review... you should repost it as a blog entry. Best regards, Vic

Comment by Triniman

Sat, 7 Aug 2004 21:21:17 EDT

Sorry, Vic! I wasn't sure if I should have posted that review or not. I try to review one new film a week, just for fun. I enjoyed your review, by the way. Cheers.

Comment by Vic

Sat, 7 Aug 2004 03:51:38 EDT

Hey Triniman, your comment isn't supposed to be better than my review. ;-) Nicely done. Vic

Comment by Triniman

Sat, 7 Aug 2004 02:52:49 EDT

4/5 The premise sounds pretty dull, doesn't it? Tom Cruise plays a hit man who coerces a cab driver to drive him around LA to knock off five people. Jamie Foxx portrays the reluctant cab driver. Director Michael Mann proves that a compelling drama doesn't require an excess in plot, car chases or violence or humour. Much of the film takes place in the cab with Cruise and Foxx exchanging philosophies of life, goals and dreams. Foxx, a cabbie for 12 years, wants to save up to open a limo service. Cruise is more enigmatic about his past, but instead is a relentless, cold-blooded assassin. Still, he's not one-dimensional at all. Cruise is excellent as the laser-focused killer with taste. Witness the scene in the jazz club to see how good his taste in music is. He's not cocky like the mastermind bad guy in the first Die Hard, but he is cool, confident and obviously emotionally detached from his victims. He doesn't care who they are since he's just doing his job. He also doesn't flash the million-dollar Cruise movie star smile. Jamie Foxx also performs well as the uncomfortable cabbie counterpoint to the Cruise character. He's just your average joe hoping to get ahead in life but obviously taking a long time to get there, just like most people. What's refreshing about this film is that it doesn't scatter the character development over too many players. The lack of comedic lines also reinforces the grittiness of the script. Michael Mann has produced a mostly believable thriller, that makes the competition look like cartoons for adults. Sure, there are stretches in the storyline but so long as you're prepared to gloss over them, this is a fine film. Collateral is also much better than Cruise's last film, the pretensioulsy bloated The Last Samurai. Anyone looking for a non-stop action film or a "Lethal Weapon"-type film should look elsewhere. Review by Triniman.

Comment by Vic

Sat, 7 Aug 2004 00:45:09 EDT

Oh! Yes. Classic. :-) Vic

Comment by visualsimplicity

Sat, 7 Aug 2004 00:43:55 EDT

Well, I didn't mean the big coincidence as the full circle, that was sort of predictable and a tad weak, but anyway. I actually meant the train thing, if you know what I mean. Now that was well done.

Comment by Vic

Fri, 6 Aug 2004 17:24:20 EDT

Yup. There was that one big coincidence, but hey, if the overall movie is well done I can cut it some slack here and there. Vic

Comment by visualsimplicity

Fri, 6 Aug 2004 17:14:26 EDT

I enjoyed this film too. Tom Cruise was quite menacing sometimes as a villian, especially at the moment that he jumped onto the train. He pulled it off quite well. I also loved how a lot of things just happened through pure chance. As you mentioned, the whole situation could have been avoided if he had daydreamed a little longer, or if Vincent hadn't heard him call out. A fleeting moment was all it took. Such is life. It goes full circle very well too.