The Duke On "The Village" - Politics, Deception and The Cinema Of Lies
Published August 05, 2004
OK Folks, Major Spoilers Coming Up. Seriously, Don't Read If You Ain't Saw The Flick.
In his review for The Harry Knowles Digest, Moriarty, or plain ol' Drew McWeeny to the taxman, states that "The Village is one of the first films by a major filmmaker to tackle post 9/11 anxiety head-on."
It'd be fairly difficult to argue with the man. Moriarty was one of the first to reveal the "twist" a few months ago, back when he got hold of a script. Back then, the twist hinged on the horrible, ridiculous line; "Stupid fucking white people".
He still feels the flick shoots itself in the foot two thirds in, but admires, among other things, these musings with regards a "culture of fear" and what not.
So, does it actually stand up under the whole post-9/11 analysis malarkey? Permit The Duke to take an in-depth peek, why don't you.
First of all, as far as, y'know, stuff like "the story" is concerned, the parallels are as pronounced as the ones Gwyneth Paltrow got all obsessed with in Sliding Doors.
Some horrendous tragedy, or number of tragedies, what led to the village elders losing those dearest to them, has resulted in these folks stepping outside society on account of sheer terror of what goes on in the big bad world.
But how do you keep the young 'uns from going and getting all inquisitive? You just tell them that the surrounding woods are filled with weird, funny-looking "others", or "Those We Do Not Speak Of", and that if you go investigating, bad things will happen.
The elders are partly justified in their actions because they have suffered a substantial loss, and have created this pervading sense of unease amongst the rest of the villagers, in some part, to ensure that it never happens again.
It's kinda like in Carrie, when the mum uses the Bible for to keep Sissy Spasek from doing shit like, I dunno, having a period and what not, or getting all obsessed with her "dirty-pillows".
The Village doesn't use the Bible. It just concocts some stuff about demons and beasts and spirits and stuff.
But the sad motherfucking truth of the matter is that, despite all the intellectual brouhaha going on, the fact remains thus; The Village is a fantastically well-directed flick, but one blighted by an awful screenplay.
Shyamalan's lack of respect for his audience oozes from the screen at times. Following a big "reveal", what informs us that the whole "creatures in the woods" thing was a load of the "bollocks", and even going so far as to show us a suit hanging on the wall of an old shed, Shyamalan tries, not five minutes later, to draw out a tense scene involving a lass being harassed by one of these fictional sons a bitches, ludicrously attempting to make it plausible by having a snippet of the voiceover saying about "There were rumors of creatures in these woods once" or some such nonsense. It's the exact same fucking suit, man.
- The Duke On "The Village" - Politics, Deception and The Cinema Of Lies
- Published: August 05, 2004
- Type:
- Section: Video
- Writer: Duke De Mondo
- Duke De Mondo's BC Writer page
- Duke De Mondo's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
While Charles M. Shultz made a decades long career out of Lucy yanking the football away from Charlie Brown, I can only think M. Mightbe Shalmalangadingdong is only delusional.
I hated with passion only the really cheated can feel, whatever that dumbass Bruce Willis movie was, no, not that one, the other one.
There's no way this charlatan will ever get his hands on any of my money for his Hollywood three-card monte.
Phil, that kinda compliment slinging means a lot to me, is what, although i think you're selling yourself short. I enjoy your writing immensley.
Jim, harsh words, man. I actually really liked m night's last three flicks. Unbreakable, i think, is a brilliant work. Everyone yacks on about the twist, tho, and i gotta admit it didnt feel like much of a revelation, really. just a natural develoment type deal. Unlike this nonsense right here. Insulted is the word, man.
It has come to my attention that Bruce Willis, while having worked on "projects" classified as "crap", "bullshit", "monkey-poo-flingingly awful" and "paycheques" in IMDB, he was granted clemency for his key role in bringing Pauly Shore and Andrew "Dice" Clay to justice in a carefully coordinated takedown in their West Hollywood "love-pad".
woe to the filmmaker who conjures the wrath of the Duke from within the gentle pool of favorable predisposition
eric, if i ever die (which, granted, is pretty far-fetched), i will ask that your comment be etched on mine tomb stone.
Actually, i'd better ask before i die.
"time check", is this some sort of Belfast Cowboy version of "Marco Polo"?
Just wondering, or did M. Shite Manfulobogusbastard put some sort wierd hex on your fevered imagination?
Blink once for yes, twice for no.


The Duke (Aaron McMullan to his parents and the clergy) is a Northern Irish writer, performer and insomniac currently residing in London. He is the creator of 





If only Praying With Anger was available on DVD to mock mercilessly!
Thanks, Duke. Your stuff always makes me laugh -- and turn green with envy. I couldn't really hope to duplicate your style, on account of I'm not into swearing and such, and plus it's your style, not mine. But that doesn't stop me from wishing. Wishing I was a better writer, is what.
Anyway, keep up the fine work.