Blogcritics: Comments on The Village

Comment by Nathaniel Winn

Tue, 3 Aug 2004 12:00:10 EDT

Hmm . . . I keep thinking that if people would stop treating M. Night's movies like gumball machines that produce surprises instead of gumballs, they would find that The Village is, in fact, quite a moving and thought-provoking bit of film. The group I saw the flick with loved it, and spent hours talking about it, and saw it again the next day. And sure enough, leaving the theater the second time, we were surrounded by comments like, "Suckiest movie ever!" and the like. Oh well.

Comment by Justene

Mon, 2 Aug 2004 18:05:03 EDT

Tom, I am pretty sure that's why they invented single malt scotch.

Comment by Tom Johnson

Mon, 2 Aug 2004 17:57:23 EDT

That's how bothered I am by it, Justene. I just can't let this crap go. I need help, therapy, pills . . . something.

Comment by Justene

Mon, 2 Aug 2004 17:06:36 EDT

How bad a movie could it have been to keep you thinking like that for 2 days?

Comment by Tom Johnson

Mon, 2 Aug 2004 16:59:58 EDT

I've spent the past couple of days thinking about why this movie was so disappointing. I think he dropped the ball, big time. In thinking about why and how he could have avoided that, I came up with a much more intriguing set of scenarios than what actually happened in the movie. If you'd like to read it, do so here, but don't do so if you don't want the story to be spoiled.

Comment by Chris Kent

Mon, 2 Aug 2004 15:27:07 EDT

Tom, Didn't mean to call you a "soccer mom," just meant that The Village will have a similar division of opinion I believe......there WILL be a lot of folks who hate it.....I'm not one of them. I too loved Blair Witch Project - a better film than The Village by far, but a film that created heated debate and angered many viewers........

Comment by Tom Johnson

Mon, 2 Aug 2004 15:18:24 EDT

Chris, I loved The Blair Witch Project - I thought it was intriguing and scary as hell. So please don't lump me in with those who can't appreciate some different and non-gory spooks. This was just an effort that falls flat in nearly every aspect. Tom, it's really difficult to address anything without giving too much away. The first giveaway to one of the two twists was in the first five minutes of the movie, involving a long focus on what might be considered just part of the setup. The clues to the other twist were more piece together than outright - once I had an idea about the one twist, the other fell into place behind it pretty quickly. I sincerely hoped that second twist wasn't going to be what I thought it was, but it turned out to be exactly what I predicted.

Comment by Tom

Mon, 2 Aug 2004 14:59:34 EDT

Tom? What are the clues you saw that gave it away? I saw the plot twists about 5 minutes before they were displayed. I thought the pacing was very good in showing the secrets; cut scenes and the like.

Comment by Chris Kent

Mon, 2 Aug 2004 14:52:43 EDT

Tom, a lot of people will have your reaction. Sort of like The Blair Witch Project......I walked out of the theater loving it, and a soccer mom standing next to me said, "That's the worst piece of shit I ever did see...."