The Duke Reviews Fahrenheit 9/11

Written by Duke De Mondo
Published June 30, 2004
page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5

This is all pretty much common knowledge nowadays, when every motherfucker on the planet wants to devote web-pages and books and albums to how incompetent and villainous and so on this presidential hack might be.

What makes it all seem fresh, vital, however, is the manner in which it is presented.

The first ten minutes of the film are a tour de force of montage editing. Sergei Eisenstein, that other left-wing film-crafter with a flair for the cutting and pasting, is no doubt looking down on Moore's work here and smiling a little, although probably thinking there should be more stone lions, really. A few more boats wouldn't go amiss, Michael, you lazy motherfucker.

However visceral this opening salvo may be, though, it is immediately kicked in the balls by Moore's reliance on mawkish, patronising sentimentality. The footage he chooses for to illustrate the events of September 11 2001 is incredibly powerful, but the manner in which he utilises it renders it fairly impotent, something unthinkable to anyone who sat staring at that news-coverage a few years back. Commendably, he doesn't show the towers at all, but what he does show, ie, grieving onlookers, bemused, weeping pedestrians, he cripples with slow-motion and a cloyingly sentimental musical score. Compare this to the footage of the columbine shooting in his last film. The CCTV footage scarring the screen with ghostly predators as anguished emergency phone calls were relayed on the soundtrack made for a deeply unsettling and incredibly powerful experience. I mean no disrespect or offence to anyone by the following statement, but the representation of 9/11 in Moore's film is laughable. Also, the inter-cutting of Bush reading to a roomful of primary school children as the events in New York unfold is intended to evoke revulsion, but the sight of this obviously bewildered individual actually goes someway to creating a sense of pity.

Which is a pretty big flaw, all being told.

It's not the only flaw, for sure. At times, there is a decidedly unpleasant hint of racism and xenophobia running through the proceedings, most evident in the round-up of coalition countries half-way in, which sees fit to represent each nation via a second long glimpse of a cultural stereotype. For the Netherlands we get a bloke smoking pot. For Morocco we get a bunch of monkeys sitting at a table. It's fairly fucking offensive, is what.

page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5
The Duke (Aaron McMullan to his parents and the clergy) is a Northern Irish writer, performer and insomniac currently residing in London. He is the creator of Mondo Irlando, wherein his scribblings and hollerings can be found. He is currently working towards the completion of his first novel, and his debut "punk / country / folk / whatever" album has recently been released by Ex Libris Records . You can also pop by His MySpace Page and maybe have a coffee and a biscuit.
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
The Duke Reviews Fahrenheit 9/11
Published: June 30, 2004
Type:
Section: Video
Filed Under: Video: Documentary, Video: News
Writer: Duke De Mondo
Duke De Mondo's BC Writer page
Duke De Mondo's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Duke De Mondo
Video: Documentary
Video: News
All Video Articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — July 2, 2004 @ 12:03PM — Chris Kent

Great work El Senor Duke. I appreciated your contrast between 911 and The Passion and a critique of the filmmaking prowess in addition to the politics. One of my favorite posts of yours.

I've seen Canadian Bacon. Very poor, and established Moore had better keep his job in the documentary arena.....

#2 — July 2, 2004 @ 13:57PM — Aaron, Duke De Mondo [URL]

Chris, thanks for the kind words! I think the comparison between this and Mel's exploitation flick is a worthwhile one, and thanks for confirming it.
I'll probably get a peek at canadian bacon sometime in the future, but i've heard many bad things, and you've just added to it lol.
But who knows? Maybe The Duke will think it's a damn masterpiece or something. Wouldn't be the first instance of such!

#3 — July 12, 2004 @ 02:13AM — Lono [URL]

Duke,

I just saw the movie tonight, and am an admitted huge fan of Moore's work... so of course I enjoyed it. One thing I thought was kinda tacky, and as a result should have been the first thing the right wingers charged on is this: he used pictures of dead babies and wounded civilians to make a point about this war. That was dumb... that stuff happens with EVERY war and it is something nobody wants or strives for. Bush has done more than enough evil shit against America to further his agenda of corporate greed and wealth that we don't need to be patronized to get the message. Geesh, that was well stated on my behalf... perhaps I should shit out a full piece on the movie myself. nah... too many already. I always enjoy your writing, and there is a huge homage to you in a very recent piece I wrote. I just can't remember which one... probably the latest Dead piece.

#4 — July 14, 2004 @ 12:45PM — Aaron, Duke De Mondo [URL]

Lono, thank you!
I searched through your blog, but couldn't find the article in question. The blog is iamcorrect, yeah? But praise the lrod, since what i found was enough to keep me occupied for longer than is socially acceptable. you are a fantastic writer, and the "from the road" entries were especially wonderful. Thank you.

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/16941)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments