From The Bottom Up: From The Fender Bass To The Software Synthesizer
Published June 17, 2004
It isn't always possible to record the bass that far along into the recording process. But because the bassist is performing a simultaneously rhythmic and melodic part, it definitely helps to at least have some sort of guide vocal and basic instrumentation in place when recording bass parts. Even if it's a vocal performance you wouldn't think of releasing, the phrasing alone can help the bassist compose a part that won't clash with the singer.
Speaking of which, just as lead vocals are frequently constructed via comping of multiple takes down to a single track, the same technique works great for the bass--and other primarily single note instruments as well.
With synthesized bass recorded as a MIDI track, it's easy to take a riff or passage and alter a note here or there to produce some variation. Obviously, that's much more difficult to do with recorded bass, although it can certainly be done with judicious editing, splicing and using pitch-changing plug-ins like the Antares Auto-Tune. But by having the bassist perform multiple takes of the same part, enough variety should be recorded to build up a world-class bass track.
One way of doing this is for the bassist's first take be played relatively conservatively, so that the melodic and harmonic foundation of the track is taken care of. Then a couple of tracks of improvisation--from slight variations maybe even up to some wild experimental playing if the tune seems to call for it--can be recorded.
Finally, the whole thing can be comped down into one complete killer track.
Soft Synths and Loops
Electric bass ultimately is rooted in relatively simple physics and engineering: one player, one physical instrument, and possibly, one amplifier. But when it comes to synthesized bass, anything goes. A track could be a 15-year-old Peavey DPM-3 or even older Yamaha DX-7 with a bass patch that's been physically played a crack session musician.
Or, it could be a soft synth like Cakewalk's Project5 or Propellerhead's Reason.
Kurt Kurasaki is the author of Power Tools For Reason 2.5. In an interview, he told me that "In some styles of electronic music, the bass riff carries the entire track, and one of the things that you lose when sequencing is performance value. Most times you end up recording eight or sixteen measures of a bass line, then duplicate it for the entire song."
To break up this monotony, Kurasaki recommends adding parameter automation or small modulations to the timbre of the bass. "I personally prefer the automation track where filter and dynamic changes are applied in real time over the duration of the track. The live automation adds life back to sequenced melody and keeps the track interesting."
- From The Bottom Up: From The Fender Bass To The Software Synthesizer
- Published: June 17, 2004
- Type:
- Section: Music
- Filed Under: Music: Recording
- Writer: Ed Driscoll
- Ed Driscoll's BC Writer page
- Ed Driscoll's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
What a great article. I'd often wondered why so many women played bass in rock bands, and asked one who was replaced in a studio session by Will Lee, and she said it was because there were fewer strings than a guitar.
Drums and bass are the two sections most replaced by machines, but I think that really opens up the field for awesome players, since machines can't do awesome yet.
Really exceptional Ed: informative, interesting, enduring. Thanks as always!
Great post; very informative.
Just a small quibble, though. I'd point to Anthony Jackson for the revolution of creating the contrabass (5 strings and more).
Casper,
That's a great point--Jackson is featured in both Jim Roberts' and Alan Slutsky's books, though. I also sort of kicked myself after writing this for not including Carol Kaye. But there are so many great players, it's tough to know when to stop.
Ed
Guys,
Thanks for the kind words--most appreciated!
Ed
As a bass player whio really wishes he'd deployed with at least one guitar to play, this clumn made me really eager to get back home and rebuild my calussed fingers. I am going to be buying a few of those books as well, thanks for the tip!
You should have mentioned the advent of affordable acoustic guitar-bodied 4 strings. I have a Sonata acoustic, only $275. but full sounding with great action, with the portability that many of us long-envied acoustic guitarists for haiving at beach parties or just sittin out back woodshedding.
once again, great column!










Speaking as a working bassist, your kung fu is the best. Thanks Ed, for a fantastic article and reverent homage to the Low End.