Blogcritics Comments on Appetite for Destruction

Comment by bhw on Appetite for Destruction

Sun, 30 May 2004 16:24:38 EDT

"Hysteria" was good, too, but not as good as "Pyromania." Or maybe it's just that "Pyro" came first and was such a pleasant surprise.

Comment by JR on Appetite for Destruction

Sun, 30 May 2004 10:04:34 EDT

What about "Hysteria"? Not enough guitar!

Comment by Kudd45 on Appetite for Destruction

Sun, 30 May 2004 08:54:45 EDT

IN H.S.? my pathetic ass still listens to def leppard weekly, lol, soo sad. No one commentated on my "other 80's rockers" rant, too bad, wanted some feedback.... oh well

Comment by RJ Elliott on Appetite for Destruction

Sat, 29 May 2004 23:19:27 EDT

Now, one of my favorite albums to headbang to in h.s. -- and one that I still like to play from time to time was Def Leppard's "Pyromania." What about "Hysteria"? POUR SOME SUGAR ON ME!!!

Comment by RJ Elliott on Appetite for Destruction

Sat, 29 May 2004 23:16:10 EDT

I have noticed that some of the snobbier BlogCritics tend to jump down the throats of those who write shorter Blog entries, as opposed to incredibly long Blog entries (which I call "Blooks"). Short posts whose goal is to start a debate/discussion (like this one) are perfectly acceptable. Methinks the complainers are simply upset that few, if any, people respond to their enormous diatribes...

Comment by BRICKLAYER on Appetite for Destruction

Fri, 28 May 2004 10:02:17 EDT

My biggest problem with Appetite for Destruction is that they have yet to issue a remastered, fancied up, expanded edition (that I'm aware of). C'mon record company devils, put this out now, so I can own my 6th copy of this (2 cassette -they warp, you know, 2 cd-sold one back during a fugue, one vinyl which is lost, never got the 8 track). As little Brick says: "More! Again!"

Comment by Eric Olsen on Appetite for Destruction

Fri, 28 May 2004 08:42:14 EDT

I will repeat over and over that all kinds of posts are welcome and legitimate as long as they say SOMETHING, provide SOME kind of information, and don't violate copyright rules. OF COURSE, in the big picture and in the long run, thorough, self-contained, essay-style reviews, commentary, obsevations, etc., are more "VALUABLE," but if that was all we ran people would get sick of those too. Everyone: just do your best and don't be lazy and all will be well.

Comment by Kudd45 on Appetite for Destruction

Fri, 28 May 2004 08:30:49 EDT

By the way, Shark's comment was mean, but not as mean as it was funny. Good job shark, keep posting such clever messages to keep people who can see the humor in life entertained.

Comment by Kudd45 on Appetite for Destruction

Fri, 28 May 2004 08:27:31 EDT

Okay G&R had their time and thier music, i do not disagree that they were a great band, but im tired of other noteworthy 80's rockers not gettin their dues. Skid Row and Cinderella were no cornier than G&R and wrote just as high quality music. Poison is still mentioned but that is only because of Every rose.. they too rocked as well as G&R. No one will probably agree with me on this but it is my two cents and i'll stand by it, lol

Comment by Chris Kent on Appetite for Destruction

Fri, 28 May 2004 08:02:37 EDT

Lono, I agree "Appetite for Destruction" is a great album, and a good blog on the fiery, short-lived meteor known as Guns N' Roses would be fascinating. But if someone wanted to read your blog and learn something new, they would have to read the thread to know just who in the hell performed on the emphasized LP...... I personally think "Los Angeles" is the greatest album of all time. I am not going to mention the band because hell, if I like them then everyone should like them....... Other great albums: "Road to Ruin" "Unleashed in the East" "II" "Kind of Blue" "Greatest Hits" "Greatest Hits Volume II"

Comment by Lono on Appetite for Destruction

Fri, 28 May 2004 03:11:50 EDT

Wow, that was a fun ride wasn't it. As for some of the wonderful mean stuff from Shark, ah never mind. Y'all were right, I did space mentioning the name of the band... but come on. I think to say Appetite for Destruction & Guns and Roses would be almost redundant. When someone says 'Dark Side of the Moon', 'Are you Experienced' or 'Physical Graffiti' do you ask who they are referring to. ah never mind, I am a huge rock dork just making references to myself. Maybe after a couple more beers I'll put up the Siamese Dream piece that has been incubating in my body for 10 years. Careful, it will be long and thoughtful. As for you Shark, just fucking skip it, plesae.

Comment by Mac Diva on Appetite for Destruction

Fri, 28 May 2004 01:08:33 EDT

Sorry, Lono. Wrong thread. Shouldn't have so many pages up at once.

Comment by Mac Diva on Appetite for Destruction

Fri, 28 May 2004 01:06:51 EDT

Though I normally ignore blog 'entries' by Al Barger, I'm dropping in to add a word of caution. Please, ladies! (And, any gents around, too.) Discussing sex on a Barger thread could lead to imagining what might occur between Barger and his significant other (himself, of course). Let's just not go there. Madonna will do fine. Her tour. And otherwise. But, let's hope Barger doesn't 'do' at all.

Comment by bhw on Appetite for Destruction

Fri, 28 May 2004 00:56:55 EDT

I like "Appetite for Destruction" a lot, even though I'm not that into the "metal" scene or whatever GnR fits into. Don't have it in my collection, though. Now, one of my favorite albums to headbang to in h.s. -- and one that I still like to play from time to time -- was Def Leppard's "Pyromania." No musical genius, just good rockin' fun. And of course, nothing compares to AC/DC's "Back in Black" for said headbanging.

Comment by Al Barger on Appetite for Destruction

Fri, 28 May 2004 00:18:24 EDT

My, but y'all are awfully HARSH on ol' Lono here. Granted this was a modest note rather than an in depth analysis, but geez. Appetite goes up there in those greatest-albums-of-all-time charts, that's for sure. I was already past being a prime teenage metal market member when this came out, and I was never much of a headbanger to start with. I might have owned ONE Zeppelin album at that point, just on general principles. Yet even I recognized that this was just absolutely the shiznit. It's mostly in the songwriting. Note that these songs are actually SONGS. They have real, honest-to-God TUNES. As a paranoid right winger, "Out Ta Get Me" has always rated high on the list, personally.

Comment by Harald on Appetite for Destruction

Thu, 27 May 2004 20:40:51 EDT

Ah. I understood 'to me' as in 'to my opinion'...

Comment by brown_boognish on Appetite for Destruction

Thu, 27 May 2004 17:14:05 EDT

It seems like he is saying its influential to him on a personal level, which seems very plausible.

Comment by Harald on Appetite for Destruction

Thu, 27 May 2004 16:00:00 EDT

Um... how was Siamese Dream influential?

Comment by Chris Kent on Appetite for Destruction

Thu, 27 May 2004 13:57:35 EDT

Is "Guns N' Roses" mentioned one fucking time in this blog?! Let's pretend I'm a Carole King fan and could give a fucking hoot about Axl & company. I decide to read this blog. How the fuck am I supposed to know who performs on this mystery album known as "Appetite for Destruction?!"

Comment by BRICKLAYER on Appetite for Destruction

Thu, 27 May 2004 13:47:56 EDT

Nick, I absolutely loved High Fidelity and About a Boy, but you lost me on How to be Good. I mean, maybe I just can't get into it when I know a male author is writing in a female voice. Especially the intimate scenes. Or maybe it was that it lacked the musical references I love oh so much. Love, Bricklayer

Comment by Nick Hornby on Appetite for Destruction

Thu, 27 May 2004 12:46:41 EDT

A thoughtful, incisive review of an important and unheralded recording, which was largely unnoticed in its time. This is why blogs are relevant!

Comment by peaceloveguidance on Appetite for Destruction

Thu, 27 May 2004 11:34:26 EDT

hhhmmm...favorite albums? Lets see, top 1000? Who's Next, TOMMY, Sticky Fingers, Sgt. Peppers, Crown of Creation (Jeff. Airplane), Morrison Hotel, Still, Closer (Joy Div.), Power, Lies, Corruption (New Ord.), Bombs and Insurance (X-15), Live at the Apollo 1954 (Lionel Hampton), Saucer Full of Secrets (Floyd). Ugh! 988 to go....

Comment by Shark on Appetite for Destruction

Thu, 27 May 2004 10:08:43 EDT

We could have cut up a newspaper article and drawn phrases at random out of a hat and gotten a better "review." Is this alleged "writer" yet more proof that "Guns N Roses" causes brain damage...?