Scott, my love.

It appears some other nerd has stolen your thunder and gotten most of the AI discussion on his blog this week. You're a better writer than he is so I'll come sit at the "uncool kids" table with you for a minute even though I wrote most of what I had to say there.

Jasmine leaving is not going out on a limb and Fantasia's victory is anything but certain.

Objectively (and this may be hard to believe because of my comments about her hideous personality in the past), I don't think Diana's singing has improved markedly. She's not all that good and hasn't really improved her technique. She's clearly more comfortable singing the more energetic songs where she can go "c'mon y'all" and belt them out, but she wouldn't have been in the top 3 in any other season. She'd be lucky to be top 10. I'm happy for her that she seems to be gaining self-confidence week-by-week but it's not a pleasant sight to see. But the story of AI has always kind of been that America likes the non-traditional types to become stars, the loser to winner stories like fat Ruben and geeky clay and white trash Kelly. LaToya was apparently too pretty and talented for America's tastes and didn't have the manic desperation for attention that Diana does. That's why Diana will win -- because she's crazy about AI like AI's crazy fans are (not to mention just plain crazy). Although I must say she'd fit in perfectly in the equally manic, phony, saccharine, cheesy environment of the Tonight Show with Jay Leno after her big "victory." I just don't want to see her porcine mother cry tears of joy -- maybe that strange woman will finally stop pushing her poor daughter to be a star if Diana wins. Doubt it, though. It'll probably only make the stage mom presence worse until Diana's "career" tanks. I actually sympathize with Diana, as unlikable as she is, the more I remember how young she is. I feel bad for what she'll go through when she wins -- oily music executives trying to make her into Hillary Duff and encouraging her to go on Atkins before her video shoot.

Jasmine's sympathy trains ends this week, although it's VERY possible Fantasia leaves. Let's not discount that possiblity. If it happens, the contest becomes a farce. Diana vs. Jasmine? JonBenet vs. Aloha Girl? Oy vey. I almost hope for that result because it would lead to a change in voting, I'd imagine, to an elimination vote. AI would take the gloves off and stop with the nicey-nice, cutesy lovefest of the bizarre. I just hope Simon's honest about his ambivalence if and when Diana wins in the interviews.

Randawg is wrong -- this wasn't the best top 12 ever. It was a freakshow.

I guess I had more to add than I thought. I hope this gets your discussion started too. That is all.

Randawg is wrong -- this wasn't the best top 12 ever. It was a freakshow.

I disagree. Whereas the previous seasons each produced 2-3 singers with potential careers, I count at least five from this season who could easily get recording contracts if they so choose: Fantasia, LaToya, Diana, Jennifer, George, and Amy. Even John Stevens or JPL could get a deal if they play their cards right.

The contestants this time around certainly had more personality than in the prior two contests, but I wouldn't necessarily call that a "freakshow."

I think your age makes you unable to comment accurately on music since you're apparently out of touch, but allow me to clarify for you.

Potential for LEGITIMATE major-label recording deals worth actual money that aren't a joke:

Fantasia: yes. It's why she won't win next week vs. Diana. America already knows Clive Davis will sign her no matter what to Jive/Arista.
LaToya: yes. might have trouble being promoted, e.g., Tamira Gray. I'm sure she'll be back on Idol singing next season.
Diana: only if she wins will she sell any records. she could be another kimberly locke in terms of recording without winning AI -- we'll see how kimberly's album sells, but I doubt it will do all that well.
George: um NO. What market does he fit into? Who's dying to buy a shuffling soul/gospel act? Is he going to fit into R & B and hip hop charts alongside Usher and Kanye West? No.
Amy: HELL NO. She got kicked off ages ago. She's chubby. She's got bad hair. She doesn't have an edge despite said bad hair and has no ability to write or play rock music on an instrument. She'll do local performances in crappy bars wherever the hell she's from and make Jay Leno cracks on stage.
John Stevens: You're on crack. NO NO and NO. No major label wants some geek who does 50s throwback stuff.
JPL: Take all those NOs for John Stevens and double them. He'll do youth community events for $500 wherever the hell he's from if he's lucky after the ridiculous American Idol Tour ends.

Personality? No. They're boring, weird, nerdy kids without anything controversial or daring about them. They're nice in a bizarro way. Maybe too nice. But make no mistake about it: FREAKSHOW.

I wouldn't watch this show for love or
money. It sure is entertaining to watch
"adults" such as yourself froth at the
mouths like Hyenas around a fresh corpse
though when it comes to arguing your points. Carry on peeps.

The extra hour is like those 'special' editions of magazines and newspapers that are just old stuff repackaged. In the news biz, we called'em 'ad rags.' No new content, but you can sell the same material twice or more. American Idol is looking cheesier and cheesier.

hola amigos de american idol, solo quiero decirles que soy un super fan del reallity show no me pierdo ningun programa y que mi favorito es fantasia barrino!!!!!!