Mean is the New Nice
Published May 01, 2004
Also at verveslag.
I have to admit that, when it opened in Chicago last night, I thought this was going to be another "so bad it's good" teen movie (which is the only type of movie I seem to be seeing lately). But, nearly ten years after the release of Clueless comes its heir apparent Mean Girls (also, here). The high art of the teen movie world, Mean Girls, like Clueless, is smart, funny (actually funny), and wise in a genre populated by vapid, unfunny imitations of imitations.
Writer/Director Amy Heckerling made Clueless great through the deft selection and use of pop culture references, which have not only stood the test of time, but make the movie play more like a satire of nineties teen culture than a relic of it. Sadly, most of her work since has been unilaterally awful. But I think we can expect more good things from SNL giant Tina Fey now that she's made her screenwriting debut (and has accomplished the feat of adapting a parenting book Rosalind Wiseman's Queen Bees and Wannabes into an entertaining movie).
Mean Girls tells the story of Cady Heron (Lindsay Lohan), who, upon returning for a prolonged research trip to Africa with her academic parents, is forced to leave home schooling to enter the real world of high school for the very first time. She gets picked up by a band of rich, popular girls called "the plastics" who attempt to mold her in their image (shades of Cher, Dionne, and Tai, anyone?). But Cady isn't in it just for kicks. It's all part of a complicated scheme that you'll have to see to believe. In any case, hilarity ensues. No, not hilarity MEAN.
It's interesting to note that Mean Girls used to be a lot more mean. In order to avoid an R rating, a number of the, well, meaner lines were cut or replaced. For example, "pop your cherry" becomes "butter your muffin" (a cryptic phrase that I don't think anyone actually understood); "masturbated with a hot dog" becomes "made out with a hot dog" (how exactly is that supposed to work?); along with the standby curse replacements. But with the heavy dose of "slut," "whore," "bitch," and "dyke," the actual effect of what changes were made is questionable at best.
A double fish-out-of-water story (Cady is from Africa, so she knows nothing about modern American culture; but she is also a normal girl masquerading as a mean girl to bring down their tribe), Mean Girls just knows what it's doing. Watch for some classic sequences in which Cady visualizes the teen world in terms of something with which she's familiar jungle law. Oh yeah, and somebody gets hit by a bus.
- Mean is the New Nice
- Published: May 01, 2004
- Type:
- Section: Video
- Filed Under: Video: Comedy
- Writer: Doug Valenta
- Doug Valenta's BC Writer page
- Doug Valenta's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us





Thanks Doug, not sure how I missed this when you first put it up.