The NHL's Latest Sucker Punch
Published March 13, 2004
Anyone remember Dave Forbes butt-ending Henry Boucha in the face, from behind, breaking his cheekbone with his stick on Jan 4, 1975? The eye injury forced him to eventually retire, and Forbes was charged by the police. Boucha still suffers from impaired depth perception and double vision. Here we are, 29 years later, and nothing has changed, only that similar incidents have happened in the interim.
Don Cherry, Domi, Tucker, and similar goons, have insisted for decades that fighting reduces tension, allows the players to let of steam, etc. This is such a load of hooey. Fight in any other team sport, and you are out of the game. The solution in hockey is simple: 1) ban fighting - you fight, you're out; 2) increase the severity of penalties for high-sticking, boarding, elbowing, etc. The result: goons will not be needed in the league anymore. What will remain are skilled players, and the quality of the game will increase dramatically. Why this will never happen? Americans want to see fighting in the game, and more viewers means more television and gate revenue, so the NHL will never move in this direction. Even Canada's favorite song about hockey doesn't mention fighting.
Recently I read that bowling is bringing in more viewers in the USA than hockey.
Duh.
- The NHL's Latest Sucker Punch
- Published: March 13, 2004
- Type:
- Section: Sports
- Writer: Randy Reichardt
- Randy Reichardt's BC Writer page
- Randy Reichardt's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
The number of fights has radically decreased in recent years. So have the ratings.
Two men facing off and punching each other for a few seconds is far different from the sucker-punch and body-slam Todd Bertuzzi delivered. The reason this stuff is news is because it is so damn rare these days.
As for the presumption that the sport of ice hockey is filled with "goons" I must disagree. Most players are highly skilled skaters, passers, and shooters. Only a few are thugs. This is much different from a few decades ago, when the skilled players were in the minority.
And, people, we need to remember that incidents that transipre during a professional sporting event are exempt from normal criminal law. Football players commit "assault and battery" every single play. Basketball and hockey players also engage in the rough stuff. That's why we pay these people millions!
The Todd Bertuzzi hit should be enough to ban him from the league, but not send him to prison. And, we should all remember, this type of behavior is a relative rarity, not the norm.
With only six teams in the Canadian market, the US market is much more lucrative for the NHL. I still believe that fighting=higher revenues in the States. As for the rarity of the Bertuzzi incident, what's rare is the degree to which the assaulted player was injured, and how he was approached - from behind. That's it. Otherwise, variations of this kind of garbage - one player not respecting another, and attemping to injure, is happening a lot. Players are being hacked, concussed, and kneed into extended time away from the game because of injuries. For years, I have felt that the check delivered by extending a leg to hit another player's knee was the cheapest, lowest kind of "check"; players such as Cam Neely and others have had their careers come to a swift close, on such plays.
The league has many skilled players, yes, but until it bans fighting and reigns in the goons like Domi, Tucker, Oliwa, Shelley, etc., incidents like this will happen again and again and again and again.
Hockey is indeed being destroyed by the people who run it.












"Americans want to see fighting in the game, and more viewers means more television and gate revenue, so the NHL will never move in this direction."
Um, I'm Canadian and while I don't watch too much hockey, Alot of my friends are obsessed by it. They all love hockey fights, and are enamored of old footage of good fights.
When Hockey Night in Canada or what have you has a showcase of the "Best fights in NHL history" they talk about it for days after. I don't know the specifics, but apparently new rules and such have lowered the ammounts of fights. My friends hate it, they consider fights to be a bonus in a hockey game. Admittedly the people I'm talking about are all around the age of 18. Maybe it's an age thing.
But I think we canadians like their violence as much as americans do.