The Margarita: A Critical Evaluation
Published December 13, 2003
In most garden variety bars, the lemon or lime juice means that atrocious sour mix they store in plastic containers. I cannot imagine a drink in which that would be tasty, but that's what you get most anywhere you order a Margarita. A more delicate bartender will use lime or lemon from frozen concentrate or better yet, freshly squeezed on the spot. If you find such a place, please tell me about it.
So how do you mix these ingredients? The common Margarita as prepared in your average Chi-Chi's is about two ounces of Tequila, one ounce of Triple Sec, an ungodly amount of sour mix, blended with ice. Ugh. Put your hands above your head and step away from the blender.
First of all, do try to stay away from that sour mix. Buy some concentrate (if it's too bitter you can add sugar to taste). Or get actual limes and lemons, cut them in half, and squeeze away. Second, get some Cointreau. Third, use decent Tequila - Sauza Hornitos is a generally accepted good choice. After that, things get flexible. The original Margarita was shaken over ice and served up (kind of like a Martini). This is particularly appealing because by careful arrangement of the ingredients, you can actually build Margaritas that have unique flavors based on the brand of Tequila.
Regarding salt: Skip the salt if you are serving your Margarita on the rocks. It's a simple matter of mechanics. Salt on the rim is intended to cause a sharp contrast with the thick sweetness of the drink. The shock to your taste buds is intended to intensify the taste experience. The salt has to hit your tongue just a brief instant before the liquid for the correct effect, if the salt taste lingers more than a tiny fraction of a second the taste buds will cower and hide and you won't enjoy your drink. This requires deft hand/tongue coordination that is hindered when you have to try to control the ice such that it won't flow out all down your face and neck when you tip the glass and cause people to think you have a drinking problem. Salt works best when your Margarita is served up. Light salt please, not a thick encrustation. Remember, the salt is simply a tool to heighten the experience of the drink, it is not a taste to be desired in and of itself.
How to make the perfect Margarita? At this point you will have noted there is some flexibility (unlike, say, a Martini, where everything must be exact). But having to make decisions is annoying, so allow me to define the perfect Margaritas (there are 2) for you:
- The Margarita: A Critical Evaluation
- Published: December 13, 2003
- Type:
- Section: Culture
- Writer: David Mazzotta
- David Mazzotta's BC Writer page
- David Mazzotta's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
Great one David, will try these out. I can't disentangle Margaritas from Mexico or at least Mexican food, or at least warm air.
I find anything with a sweet mixer gets cloying after a while, hence I don't have to worry about Fru-Fru.
I have always wondered whether pricier liquor is noticeably better. In Robert Cialdini's book, Influence (I think), the author described the marketing of Crown Royal (or Chevas Regal?). The makers had originally intended to sell it as a cheap liquor. But sales were not good. Changing plans, they raised the price and marketed it as an expensive, classier liquor. It sold much better.
Even so, I will take your advice and use the recommended Margarita ingredients. Do you have any preferred ways to overcome hangovers? Also, would you put the mint julep in the category of fru-fru drink?
i find that drinking a Bloody Mary during the night out ensures no hangover the next day.
Tomato juice, 4 shots of (chilli pepper) vodka, and a dash of tobasco
mix it all up. Drink through a straw. It tastes like cold, spicy tomato soup.
jadester: That description made me cringe. I can only assume you live in a college town.
Jan:
I have never found anything that helps a hangover except time.
A Mint Julep, if made in the traditional way - sugar/simple syrup, bourbon, and a mint leaf garninsh - is definitely NOT a fru-fru drink. It is a drink for large, southern, cigar-smoking men, who call women "little phillies".
The margarita is merely the overdressed sister of the daiquiri. And, boy, have I missed the bittersweet wonder since moving away from the East Coast.
Nice recipe. Friend who lived in St. Thomas 20+ years says they need to be made with key limes, the little tiny limes that are ripe when yellow. After tasting his pitcher made with such, I'd have to agree.
Cheers






the one thing you have missed is:
drinking "fru-fru" drinks from jugs. 2 pint jugs.
- a local restaurant has half-price coktails, including their jugs, on a thursday - that's £5 for a 2 pint jug.
"How many glasses would you like with that?"
"None..."