"City of New Orleans": best train song ever?

Written by bookofjoe
Published November 11, 2003

So said Kris Kristofferson. Though the song was recorded by Judy Collins, it hit big when Arlo Guthrie recorded it in 1972. Few people know that it was written, however, by a guy named Steve Goodman.

As to the "best train song ever": Kristofferson should know: he probably has heard/played every train song ever written/sung. Which reminds me of a now-defunct feature of the weekend Financial Times: it was called "Experts' Experts", and asked four experts in a field (race car drivers, sculptors, soccer players, fashion designers) who were the greatest ever in their fields. Completely compelling.

I LOVE stuff like this. In fact, this is why I started reading the weekend Financial Times, just for this feature (I already get/read daily The New York Times, Washington Post, Wall St. Journal, USA Today, Richmond Times-Dispatch, Washington Times, and the Charlottesville Daily Progress; once a week come The New Yorker, Sports Illustrated, and the Economist: hey, I cover it ALL for you!).

Anyhow, a couple months ago, Experts' Experts vanished. Simply disappeared! I emailed the Financial Times but got a form reply. The weekend edition turns out to be so good anyhow, though, that I buy it regardless, and finally, last week, I succumbed to their persistent intoductory offers and sent in a check for a 26-week trial subscription, the FT delivered with my other papers six mornings a week.

I gave in because 3 out of 4 weekends, when I go out Sunday to get the weekend issue, it's sold out or never even arrived at Kroger, Giant, Barnes & Noble, and the one newsbox in town that stocks it.

Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Buy from Amazon.com
The Best of Arlo Guthrie The Best of Arlo Guthrie
Arlo Guthrie
Music,
Forever: An Anthology Forever: An Anthology
Judy Collins
Music,

"City of New Orleans": best train song ever?
Published: November 11, 2003
Type:
Section: Music
Writer: bookofjoe
bookofjoe's BC Writer page
bookofjoe's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by bookofjoe
All Music Articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — November 11, 2003 @ 12:49PM — Jim Carruthers [URL]

If you are looking for train songs, add Gordon Lightfoot to your list, plus on the jazz side Oscar Peterson's Canadiana Suite (his father was a train porter).

After all, Canada is a country which exists because of a railroad, it was one of the key reasons for Confederation in 1867.

#2 — November 11, 2003 @ 16:46PM — Eric Olsen

Elvis Presley's "Mystery Train" is pretty hard to beat. There are a ton of great blues train songs, including Robert Johnson's "Love In Vain," which the Stones didn't do a shabby job of on Get Yer Ya-Ya's Out.

#3 — November 11, 2003 @ 16:47PM — Eric Olsen

And I knew it was by Steve Goodman, by the way, an excellent Chicago singer-songwriter who died young of cancer - it sucked.

#4 — November 11, 2003 @ 16:59PM — JR

What about "Take the 'A' Train"? The Clifford Brown/Max Roach version even starts off with a musical imitation of a train.

#5 — November 11, 2003 @ 17:18PM — Eric Olsen

Doesn't Bowie's "TVC 15" start off with train noise building into a rhythm?

#6 — November 11, 2003 @ 17:24PM — Craig Lyndall [URL]

Gladys Knight - Midnight Train to Georgia

Other than that....

Guns N' Roses - Night Train?

#7 — November 11, 2003 @ 17:57PM — duane

Whiskey Train by Procul Harum, Robin Trower playing a nasty guitar.

#8 — November 11, 2003 @ 18:04PM — Eric Olsen

"Night Train" by James Brown, of course

#9 — November 11, 2003 @ 18:48PM — Mac Diva [URL]

I nominate "Midnight Train," featuring the magificient Buddy Guy and the superb Jonny Lang . Can't touch that!

#10 — November 11, 2003 @ 18:51PM — JR

"Train Wreck" was a favorite with my Jazz Band class, although I don't recall ever seeing the sheet music to it. The teacher never let us finish it, either.

#11 — November 11, 2003 @ 20:27PM — Eric Olsen

And then there's the Clash's... Never mind, that's about something else.

#12 — November 11, 2003 @ 21:32PM — Taloran

Blackfoot's "Train Train" from Strikes. It might date me a bit, but man did I love that when I was 16!

The Band's "Mystery Train", especially the live version on The Last Waltz, with Paul Butterfield's wistful, longing blues harp sound soooo trainlike.

#13 — November 11, 2003 @ 21:36PM — duane

Some of my favorites:

"Train of Fools" by Aretha Franklin

"Untrained Melody" by The Righteous Brothers (RIP, Bobby)

"Who'll Stop the Train" by Creedence Clearwater Revival

#14 — November 11, 2003 @ 21:40PM — Taloran

re 9 by Mac Diva -
I think Jonny Lang needs to spend 20 years on the road, eating lukewarm meals in cheesy diners and living out of rat-infested motels and boarding houses to get the same kind of blues soul as the true greats he imitates. You wanna sound like the masters, gotta live like 'em. I'm sure he'd disagree with the 20 years of lousy living part.

That said, he wields a mean axe. I just think his vocals have a ways to go before he can be ranked with the Muddys, B.B.'s, Slowhands and Willie Dixons (not to mention several hundred others).

#15 — November 11, 2003 @ 22:13PM — Tom Johnson [URL]

Don't forget Bruce Cockburn's "Night Train." Not a cover of the Guns N Roses song. Great driving, chugging tune, too.

#16 — November 11, 2003 @ 23:09PM — Mac Diva [URL]

Tal, Jonny has a great mentor. It is amazing to have been taken under the wing of Buddy Guy as a snot-nosed kid. I hope the lil' whippersnapper appreciates his good fortune.

#17 — November 11, 2003 @ 23:22PM — Taloran

MD, Buddy paid his dues, along with all the other blues greats through the years. I think it's fantastic that Mr. Guy (I feel uncomfortable calling him Buddy) has blessed this kid with his wisdom and experience, in the same way that Ted Williams blessed Tony Gwynn with his own. Tony turned out all right (best career batting average since Ted himself) and I hope Jonny does the same in his field. I'm simply stating that he hasn't proven himself to me yet (not that he gives a rat's tail if he ever proves himself to me).

Whitney Houston had a great voice when she first appeared on the scene - but did she compare, in those early years, to the world-class divas who came before (Ella, Etta, Billie, Sarah, et al)? Of course not. All I'm saying is that Jonny has a difficult road to walk before he gets to the place he wants to go.

#18 — November 12, 2003 @ 00:41AM — Al Barger [URL]

Don't forget "Night Train" from Rickie Lee Jones' classic eponymous debut album, about a single mother fleeing from welfare agents who want to take her baby.

#19 — November 12, 2003 @ 07:40AM — Tim Hall [URL]

Not every train song has the word train in the title.

What about "Lucitania Express" by Gillan, or "5:15" by The Who?

#20 — November 12, 2003 @ 08:14AM — Eric Olsen

what, no "Chattanooga Choo-Choo"?

#21 — November 12, 2003 @ 12:23PM — JR

Doobie Brothers: "Long Train Runnin'"

Pat Metheny: "Last Train Home"

Cream: "Traintime"

Beatles: "One After 909"

Blue Oyster Cult: "Hot Rails To Hell"

#22 — November 12, 2003 @ 12:33PM — Eric Olsen

"Casey Junior" from Dumbo

#23 — November 13, 2003 @ 16:04PM — Tim Hall [URL]

Jethro Tull's "Locomotive Breath"

Saxon's "Princess of the Night"

Who was it that did a song called "Deltics"?


I can also think of several albums with trains on the cover artwork, most notably Phil Manzenra's "Diamond Head" and Blur's "Modern Life is Rubbish".

#24 — November 29, 2007 @ 15:12PM — Jason Sparks

I would like to propose an addition to this list--it's an incredible song--but I cannot find an artist or title. It's playing on our local Christian station now, as they're doing all Christmas music. It's a spoken-word song--the speaker sounds like Keith Carradine, so help me--and he is riding a train at night, in a car containing himself, a sleeping passenger, and a mother & baby. He begins to reminisce about warm, gentle-but-not-treacly Christmases past with his family; coming back to reality, he is inspired to hold (and thus keep warm) the mother & child. I'm doing it no justice here--I will not let anyone make a peep when it comes on. Familiar?

#25 — December 17, 2007 @ 15:17PM — BT [URL]

Tthe Train=Geoffrey Lewis father of Juliette Lewis

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/10021)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments