You've asked for it

Written by Corinna Hasofferett
Published November 01, 2003

Since Eric has been so persistent and persuasive in his gallant efforts to join us all in yours Halloween merriment, I finally gave in, and here is my contribution.

I happen to be merry throughout the year, yet being stubborn, I find it difficult to respond in kind today, no matter what the calendar requires.

It so happened that in my frustration I reached out to Dawn's place, and found her somehow in the same sober mood.

What follows is my response to commentators over there. So now it's like what politicians and religions daily offer: The answers.

While we are required by History later on, to come up with the questions.

Which you might find on Dawn's Israel vs. The World:

James, it could also be that as long as there are wars, there'll be religions.

Ren, "shutting the doors on them" was done since time remembered, especially during the Holocaust, the Armenian genocide - the list is long.

Allison, how do you know the Palestinians got the best offer ever? It's not what peace activists here claim, backed by historians, politicians and army veterans in Israel.

This is not even relevant as each moment is a new one, most of the time.
Not in my region, where the practise is - Revenge for Revenge.

Yes, The USA could have strongly helped in stopping that ritual, yet the world still is in need of a real leader. I find it hard to discern one in yours, nor in the elevated persons wrecking havoc in our area.

Since in our times it is not possible to close the doors on Evil, it is your responsibility, no less than ours, to ask the present leader in one's country stop the madness of Revenge, and have us sitted at the negotiating table.

And I'm sorry to conclude that your request might be more effective than ours here, on both sides of The Insecurity Wall.

Meanwhile, we seem to have Haloween visited upon us daily, while politicians visit us with their old tricks, and get us so well treated.

****************************************************************

P.S. the Amazon links lead to books in which the Israeli military historian Col. (retired) and former M.P., Meir Pail is frequently quoted.
Yesterday I had the pleasure of meeting with him and heard his own insightful comments.

Unknown Territory This is one of the more unusual books to have been published recently in Israel. It's also a book that's hard to categorize. It's not a standard novel, not really a book of memoirs, not actually a work of history - but it is a book that offers a different, surprising take on Israel's first years. A loving and painful take, to resort to a cliche. Corinna Hasofferett, embarked on this literary journey in the wake of two friends who were with her in a youth movement and were killed in Israel's cross-border reprisal raids. For years she collected testimonies of people who knew them, taping and editing. She interweaves the testimonies, almost without intervention on her part. The result is a narrative flow that revives the period without any prettification or mythologizing. She jokingly describes the book, "B'Eretz Lo Yadati" ("Unknown Territory," in English), as a Fighters Talk - referring to the famous book ("Siah Lohamim") in which soldiers described their experiences in the 1967 Six-Day War - but with no censorship. There are a few interesting revelations in the book, apart from the story of Yehuda Kan Dror. For example, confessions about the killing of captives, or a surprising confession from a member of Unit 101 - the precursor of the Paratroops, Unit 101 was established by Ariel Sharon in the early 1950s - that the unit did not have any fatalities because it operated almost exclusively against civilian targets. But concentrating on these aspects of the book could be misleading. It offers a far broader picture of a society that was still licking its wounds from the War of Independence, the picture of a country in which the signs of the previous Palestinian inhabitants were still visible, a picture of people whose memory of the Holocaust is not something they learned in school. This is Corinna's sixth book, and she has published it herself - both for economic reasons and also to avoid having an outside eye that might cut sensitive passages. So it's not easy to find the book in bookstores. But it's worth making the effort. Corinna's books, in Hebrew, are available for purchase directly from her Hebrew blog: http://www.notes.co.il/corinna/1823.asp
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
You've asked for it
Published: November 01, 2003
Type:
Section: Politics
Writer: Corinna Hasofferett
Corinna Hasofferett's BC Writer page
Corinna Hasofferett's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Corinna Hasofferett
All Politics Articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/9746)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments