Blogcritics Comments on Not Halloween, Reformation Day!

Comment by Becky from Baton Rouge on Not Halloween, Reformation Day!

Tue, 31 Oct 2006 12:27:26 EST

I spelled likelihood wrong in my earlier piece. Oops.

Comment by Becky from Baton Rouge on Not Halloween, Reformation Day!

Tue, 31 Oct 2006 12:25:54 EST

Reformation Day is to be praised. It is one of the reasons why my faith in God runs so deep and so strong, but I am also a little weary of "fall carnivals". Trick or Treating is great for kids, but I think a fall carnival as a supplement might not be a bad idea as well. As long as they aren't holding the carnival just to eschew trick or treating, I'm fine with it. But, the liklihood of that being true is slim. You wouldn't understand, nor would we expect you to, the power of Reformation Day unless you were a Christian who has surrendered your life to Christ.

Comment by Phillip Winn on Not Halloween, Reformation Day!

Mon, 31 Oct 2005 17:27:02 EST

Nancy, I have never tried carrying a hammer. Perhaps that's what my costume is missing!

Comment by Phillip Winn on Not Halloween, Reformation Day!

Mon, 31 Oct 2005 17:26:37 EST

I was at a party Saturday night where someone had a "monk" wig. It wasn't nearly as good as the real thing. My head, as it is now, gets looks. :-) Tomorrow I'll shave it all off to match, which I do every now and then anyway, so it's not so bad for me.

Comment by Lise on Not Halloween, Reformation Day!

Mon, 31 Oct 2005 15:04:54 EST

Funny ... I have seen the movie Luther, but honestly didn't know there was a "reformation day". I learned about it at Church while I was incharge of the nursery last Sunday. My friend talked about how she wanted to celebrate that instead of doing Harvest festival at another Church, which is all there seems to be around our area. I did the Halloween thing growing up, and that was ALL it was to me. I know better NOW, so I won't celebrate Halloween. We will be going to a Harvest festival this year. But I like this idea. This is an alternative that could include possible games, and stories, which if you ask me is way better then just dressing up going house to house ... I love it! To late this year, but maybe next year! A celebration of how Martin Luther changed our faith! Without the 95 Thesis ... what would our faith be today? Definitly worth celebrating! I'm going to talk to my friend, and maybe we can organize something in the Church. That would be so fun. As for shaving your head ... being a woman myself ... if my husband did it ... well ... I would be upset. lol But EVENTUALLY I'd forgive him. I'd make him shave it all off the next day though, or that night. lol NO way would he go around like that until the hair grew back in that bald spot. lol You could always get a wig with a bald spot in it. I'm sure there's a costume place somewhere that'll sell "monk" hair. lol Good luck with that!

Comment by Nancy on Not Halloween, Reformation Day!

Mon, 31 Oct 2005 15:03:04 EST

I've got to admit, if you were just dressed as monk, I'd figure you were generic, but if you're walking around w/something labeled "95 Theses" & a hammer, I'd have a clue, at least. Oh, well.

Comment by Phillip Winn on Not Halloween, Reformation Day!

Mon, 31 Oct 2005 14:56:05 EST

Nancy, not many. I expected zero, and I've gotten more than that, but not a lot more. :-)

Comment by Dave Nalle on Not Halloween, Reformation Day!

Mon, 31 Oct 2005 14:25:03 EST

Screw Reformation Day. I'm building a wicker cage and looking for our cat. Dave

Comment by Nancy on Not Halloween, Reformation Day!

Mon, 31 Oct 2005 13:56:53 EST

Actually, I think that's rather witty as well as informative - the Martin Luther thing & all. How many people look at you and "get it"? Can't give you an assessment on shaving your head, tho; that will have to be between you, your conscience, & your wife.

Comment by Phillip Winn on Not Halloween, Reformation Day!

Mon, 31 Oct 2005 13:42:01 EST

Boring person that I am, I'm reprising the costume again this year, though this year I did shave my head! Happy Halloween, Happy Reformation Day, and enjoy All Saints Day tomorrow!

Comment by Megan on Not Halloween, Reformation Day!

Mon, 31 Oct 2005 13:22:30 EST

Hello. My two year old will be going to our church's Reformation Party as the 95 theses nailed to the door. It is our goal to bless our children above and beyond what they would ever experience as mere trick or treaters and give them a certain joy concerning such a critical event in church history. Even if we are bobbing in "providence pond" I appreciate that you are dressed up and not going around grumbling about "pagan holidays" Actually, I found your page while trying to google '95 theses costume'.....

Comment by Victor Plenty on Not Halloween, Reformation Day!

Thu, 28 Oct 2004 19:27:31 EDT

Good on ya, Phillip! You show how the "true" meaning of old pagan festivals, once co-opted by Christians and then later re-co-opted by modern popular culture, is still a bit of a cultural battlefield. The churches don't seem to be taking a very strong position in this battle by holding October "Harvest" parties, or even with "Reformation Day." Whatever happened to their old strategy: calling it the eve of All Saints' Day? Did the Protestants drop that approach just because they don't like saints quite so much anymore? Not that it matters so much, really. Now that the Halloween shopping season is starting to get as lucrative as the Christmas shopping season, the power to define the meaning of this holiday is settling into the firm grip of the grasping hands of commerce. Now that's scary.

Comment by Dave Watson on Not Halloween, Reformation Day!

Thu, 28 Oct 2004 17:43:48 EDT

Looking for some Children's materials for Reformation Day - some graphics for a Sunday School

Comment by Chaplain Wiedeman on Not Halloween, Reformation Day!

Thu, 14 Oct 2004 18:36:05 EDT

I am looking for the copyright holders of Christian videos, without much success. If you know of any way to find them, please let me know. Ordinary searches on the internet have been unfruitful. Thanks Robert E. Wiedeman, Chaplain

Comment by Phillip Winn on Not Halloween, Reformation Day!

Sat, 1 Nov 2003 16:12:05 EST

And yes, I counted PCA churches among the half-billion or so direct descendants of Luther.

Comment by Phillip Winn on Not Halloween, Reformation Day!

Sat, 1 Nov 2003 16:08:33 EST

By the time I went door-to-door with the kids, I did have two copies of Luther's 95 Theses, one in the original Latin and one in English, just in case somebody asked me to read them. My wife strongly suggested that nobody would care one whit about Luther versus a generic monk, but the 95 Theses did the trick. I had two different people ask me if I planned to nail them to any door in the area... Though I attend a reformed Episcopal church, the aren't doing anything special for the holiday, probably because the rector is out of town speaking at the consecration of a new bishop this weekend. And no beer in the house, either. Oh well.

Comment by Chris Arabia on Not Halloween, Reformation Day!

Fri, 31 Oct 2003 12:37:45 EST

95 theses? where's emily litella when you need her?

Comment by Natalie Davis on Not Halloween, Reformation Day!

Fri, 31 Oct 2003 12:24:26 EST

Happy Reformation Day! Interestingly, many of the Roman Catholic Church's woes can be traced directly to the grievances Luther nailed to that wall 486 years ago today.

Comment by Kurt Nordstrom on Not Halloween, Reformation Day!

Fri, 31 Oct 2003 11:54:54 EST

They had a Reformation Day party at the Presby church that my wife and I have been visiting. I think, ironically, enough, that it was on Wednesday. Go figure. About the head-shaven thing. This is just another case where it is easier to get forgiveness than permission. Act, don't discuss!

Comment by JG on Not Halloween, Reformation Day!

Fri, 31 Oct 2003 11:14:23 EST

Islam needs a Martin Luther of its own. And Fox News is not 'Fair and Balanced'; it is just much closer to neutral than the other TV news organizations. MSNBC is trying though.

Comment by andy on Not Halloween, Reformation Day!

Fri, 31 Oct 2003 11:07:29 EST

Happy Reformation Day to you as well! As a member of the Presbyterian Church of America, Reformation day is a big deal to me! Our denomination stays true to the teachings of Luther and reformed faith as taught by people like Luther and John Calvin, so my doctrine owes a lot to Martin Luther. Hooray for Reformation Day!