Hidden identities aren't just for Halloween!

Written by Eric Scheie
Published October 30, 2003
page 1 | 2 | 3

  • frighten critics and potential converts by a combination of carrot (work in your campaign and give you money) and stick (threats, ostracism, ad hominem attacks) Techniques quite similar, I might note, to what Arthur Silber describes here.
  • While there appears to be somewhat of a genuine theological split between Christian Reconstructionists and other fundamentalist sects, the stealth nature of the Christian Reconstructionists tends to obscure its nature. (All the more reason to promote not only the First Amendment, but the reasoning behind it.)

    But stealth and hidden agendas are what give these minorities the power to dominate majorities. Through stealth, minorities on the left and the right are able to dominate most of the American political process. Americans do not especially like identity politics, because it is profoundly un-American. But when the fanatic identity politicians are able to grab control of each major party, they can then pose as representing the entire country by pointing to each other as "alternatives" — to the exclusion of the majority.

    A lot of people have been talking about third parties. Arnold Schwarzenegger might as well have been a third party. In a normal election, the Republican minority activist consensus would have guaranteed a primary victory for McClintock (whose campaign, not coincidentally, was run by a Christian Reconstructionist) — and, ultimately, another Democratic victory, not because the voters love the Democrats, but because the Democrats' version of rule by multiple identity politics groups is less threatening than the Republicans' "Party of God."

    Fuller voter participation is the best way to stop this tyranny by activist minorities. It won't happen through the primaries. Voters need, simply, to have alternatives to those who hide behind cutthroat identity politics.

    Identity politics is like gang membership, born out of a desire to belong, and a form of mob rule. It is based on emotion rather than thought. Voters reject it if given a chance, but it is very powerful — and not always what it appears to be.

    Just don't make the mistake of thinking it's limited to the left.


    NOTE: The above post can also be read at my blog.

    page 1 | 2 | 3
    Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
    Hidden identities aren't just for Halloween!
    Published: October 30, 2003
    Type:
    Section: Politics
    Writer: Eric Scheie
    Eric Scheie's BC Writer page
    Eric Scheie's personal site
    Spread the Word
    Like this article?
    Email this
    Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
    RSS Feeds
    All RSS Feeds (240+)
    Comments on this article
    BC articles by Eric Scheie
    All Politics Articles
    All BC articles
    All BC Comments

    Comments

    #1 — October 30, 2003 @ 08:37AM — debbie

    Very thought provoking piece.

    I have listened to Dr. James Dobson, he comes up on our local Christian radio station, I have never heard him say that homosexual should be imprisoned. I don't know the other two that you mentioned.

    I would have to agree that there are fanatics in any organization, people that believe that they have the insight and thus this gives them permission to ride roughshod over everybody else to get them to see "what is right". There are people in the Green party, Libertarian party, in you local groups, etc. That is the nature of things. There is always a bell curve, and there will always be extremists at both sides of an issue.

    #2 — October 30, 2003 @ 09:56AM — Eric Olsen

    pretty amazing Eric, very important. I think you are doing the very best thing you can do in shining a light onto these processes. Thanks!

    Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

    Add your comment, speak your mind

    (Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/9628)

    Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





    Remember Name/URL?

    Please preview your comment!

    Fresh
    Articles
    Fresh
    Comments