The Greening of Greendale

Written by Rodney Welch
Published October 24, 2003

I put off buying Neil Young's Greendale when it came out two months ago because I wanted to come up to speed on his past. It's a bookish affectation on my part, I know --this tendency to view major atists as mountains to climb, start at the bottom and work your way up, earliest to latest, worst to best, best to worst, whatever formula feels right at the time. I tend to avoid artists in their latest or most popular incarnation, because they already have everyone else's attention, and because you're only getting the latest chaper of the story, and maybe not the best chapter. Jimmy McDonough's bio Shakey had already made it abundantly clear that I've either forgotten a lot of high points of Young's career or simply missed them altogether.

I want to say Greendale is Neil Young's best work in years, but I haven't really followed his work of the past decade. I've focused over the past few months on his peak years of the 1970s, which is also when I first discovered him. It's too early to say that Greendale is on par with, say, Tonight's the Night or Rust Never Sleepsbut it certainly has epic ambition, and it has obviously inspired him in a major way, as if he has pursued and uncorked some major statement that he wants everyone to hear. The disc is 78 wordy-but-never-wearisome minutes long, with some cuts clocking in at the I-can't-stop-writing ten and twelve minute mark, and it comes with a DVD of the songs performed live. There's also an exhaustive website, a reportedly theatrical tour, and a movie of some kind is reportedly in the works. The latter isn't the greatest news, as Young's previous cinematic adventures rank him as a film auteur of the Frank Zappa or Bob Dylan stripe, i.e., he makes unwatchable movies with often exceptional scores.

Distinct from Young's other records, Greendale has a somewhat literary scope to it, as if Young wanted to write a rock and roll Great American Novel, full of fascinating characters and a plot both tragic and strange that says something of enormous import about the times we live in. There's Grandfather Green, a stately old coot who reflects a time gone by, his son Earl, Earl's wife Edith, their daughter Sun Green — who reminds me a bit of Prairie Wheeler in Thomas Pynchon's novel Vineland — and Earl's dope-dealing brother Jed. When Jed guns down a police officer named Carmichael, the family is placed in the media spotlight, which rather spontaneously brings on the grandfather's heart-attack and — for reasons that aren't entirely clear — inspires the young Sun's career as an environmental activist.

page 1 | 2
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Buy from Amazon.com
Greendale (Bonus DVD) Greendale (Bonus DVD)
Neil Young & Crazy Horse
Music,
On the Beach On the Beach
Neil Young
Music,
After the Gold Rush After the Gold Rush
Neil Young
Music,
Decade Decade
Neil Young
Music,
Tonight's the Night Tonight's the Night
Neil Young
Music,
Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere
Neil Young & Crazy Horse
Music,

The Greening of Greendale
Published: October 24, 2003
Type:
Section: Music
Writer: Rodney Welch
Rodney Welch's BC Writer page
Rodney Welch's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Rodney Welch
All Music Articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — October 24, 2003 @ 16:47PM — Eric Olsen

great job, I still haven't heard this (seem to be off the WEA list for now). I am a very firm Neil fan - I actually LIKE him better than Dylan though Dylan is doubtless more important

#2 — October 24, 2003 @ 17:49PM — James Bondage

Greendale is a classic. I saw 2 of the shows this past summer where a stage production accompanied the music. The subject matter jumps around from cop killers, to the intrusive media, environmentalism, religious wars, etc... but the music is the real story here.

This set is raw, with a bluesy folk flavor. I agree with the reviewer that it resembles his 70's Album ZUMA. Same style and feel.

Neil Young is the only artist I know that can take a 2-chord song like "Carmichael" or "Grandpa's Interview", and stretch it into a 10-15 minute classic, blending great blues solos between verses and tempo changes with pure raw emotion. It works, brilliantly.

I read an interview where Young explained that when he recorded this, each song was basically recorded with one take, placing microphones about 5 feet away from the band. If you listen closely to the last song "Be The Rain" you'll notice that about half way through, at about the 5:30 mark, the snare drum blows out and they just keep going.

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/9480)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments