Luther: A Review

Written by Sean Hackbarth
Published September 27, 2003

The new historical movie Luther takes us to the history-making moment when the Catholic Church no longer had a monopoly on the Christian faith in Europe. As it said at the end of the movie, Martin Luther affected the politics, economics, as well as religion of the continent.

Joseph Fiennes pulls off an Oscar-calibre performance as Martin Luther. His portrail of the conflict within was outstanding. We see the tortured soul dealing with salvation, damnation, and temptation. His thrashing and yelling at the devil reminds me of Smegal in the second Lord of the Rings movie. Peter Ustinov played Luther's benefactor, Prince Fredrick. He did a great job with great wit and a keen use of subtle facial features. The settings and costumes were gorgeous. The mud, dirt, and heavy clothing reminds you that this is set in the 16th Century

As a historical epic we do get to see what effect Luther's ideas had on Germany. Peasants took his rejection of Roman authority to heart and revolted. Luther was appalled and asked the ruling princes to put down the revolt. The princes also used Luther's Reformation as a means to oppose Charles, the Holy Roman Emperor. Roger Ebert does make a good point that there wasn't enough description of the political background of the time. Attempts were made by characters like Pope Leo X to mention the Turks were threatening Vienna, but more could have been done.

Catholics probably won't be too fond of this movie. Rome is called a "sewer" where priests sleep with prostitutes and commerce (in the form of indulgences) was more important than spirituality.

I'd love this movie to get some Oscar consideration. Fiennes and Ustinov shine; and Jonathan Firth, who plays Cardinal Aleandro, makes for a sly, cunning adversary. I wouldn't go so far as to say Luther should get best-picture consideration. It's too much of a morality play where all the characters are either good or bad. What Luther is is a story of man challenging the most powerful institution of his time and winning. As that, this is a fine movie.

Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Luther: A Review
Published: September 27, 2003
Type:
Section: Video
Writer: Sean Hackbarth
Sean Hackbarth's BC Writer page
Sean Hackbarth's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Sean Hackbarth
All Video Articles
Sean Hackbarth's personal weblog
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — September 27, 2003 @ 09:43AM — andy

My entire church doctrine springs from what Luther did and taught. I hope this movie stays true to the spirit of the Reformation.

#2 — September 27, 2003 @ 15:00PM — Sean Hackbarth [URL]

I think it does. It's not theologically heavy, but I didn't notice any problems.

#3 — September 27, 2003 @ 20:47PM — The Theory

that period of time is so facinating.

#4 — September 28, 2003 @ 15:03PM — Sean Hackbarth [URL]

The period is as much a time of change as the 18th Century is in Neal Stephenson's Quicksilver. Local authorities were opposing far away institutions. Peasants had enough of their chains. The printing press allowed ideas to spread quickly. Amazing times indeed.

#5 — September 29, 2003 @ 18:13PM — Phillip Winn [URL]

I'm not sure that Roman Catholics should be offended by this movie. While the church did not respond well to Luther at the time, excommunicating him, they did eventually adopt nearly every one of his suggested reforms. It is a point of argument whether the Jesuit reformation would have ever happened if Luther's hadn't first, but...

Well, I'm getting off track, but the point is that it is historical, not current. Well-made movies about dark episodes of America's past are generally popular with Americans, and I see no reason why this movie wouldn't be popular with Roman Catholics.

Just think of it as a reminder, and consider "how far we've come."

Er, not that I'm a Roman Catholic, but I'm just saying...

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/8714)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments