Pete Yorn - "Very bad, very annoying."

Written by Amber Nussbaum
Published June 02, 2003

Okay. I can understand not liking an artist/band that imitates another, and does it badly. I can understand that.

Kevin Canfield doesn't like Pete Yorn because he thinks he tries to be Bruce Springsteen, and doesn't live up to The Boss. But this quote bothered me in his little Yorn rant on Salon.com.

    In a way, Yorn is everything that is wrong with contemporary rock and pop. The epitome of a mediocre (but carefully packaged) soulful white boy who looks good in publicity photos, he represents something very bad and very annoying about the relationship between labels and the rock writers who make careers of regurgitating press releases.

Everything that's wrong with it? Very bad and very annoying? Dang.

What did he do, but look good in some photos? Canfield talked about Pete's hair and soulful looks an awful lot, talked about his record packaging, says "the kid doesn't have the goods," but never actually talks about his music. This upsets me.

Okay so maybe he is a pretty boy. Maybe he did pattern his approach to rock after Springsteen's. But what about his music? What about the fact that after I bought Musicforthemorningafter it didn't leave my CD player for weeks. That I know every word, every chord on that record. That he covers Bowie's China Girl and The Smiths' Panic superbly. That his live show is laid back and energetic and exciting at the same time. That his lyrical quality makes it so easy to identify with his topics, and has just enough of a poetic quality to make you listen to the track again. And I could go on.

Go ahead and joke Pete's hair. Joke his wistful looks. But for god's sake if you're gonna make statements like he's "everything that's wrong" with rock music, back it up with something other than opinions on his appearance. Thanks.

To hear me run my mouth some more, see photos, read CD and show reviews, and catch up on scene drama, kick over to www.myaimistrue.com.

Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Buy from Amazon.com
Day I Forgot Day I Forgot
Music,
Musicforthemorningafter (with Bonus CD) Musicforthemorningafter (with Bonus CD)
Pete Yorn
Music,
Bruce Springsteen - Greatest Hits Bruce Springsteen - Greatest Hits
Bruce Springsteen
Music,
Born to Run Born to Run
Bruce Springsteen
Music,
Singles Singles
The Smiths
Music,
Best of Bowie Best of Bowie
David Bowie
Music,

Pete Yorn - "Very bad, very annoying."
Published: June 02, 2003
Type:
Section: Music
Filed Under: Music: Alternative Rock, Music: Folk, Music: Pop, Music: Rock
Writer: Amber Nussbaum
Amber Nussbaum's BC Writer page
Amber Nussbaum's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Amber Nussbaum
Music: Alternative Rock
Music: Folk
Music: Pop
Music: Rock
All Music Articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — June 2, 2003 @ 14:07PM — Tom Johnson [URL]

My wife, a Yorn fan, was quite upset by this article, voicing everything in his defense that you voiced. I agree, and while I wouldn't say I'm a "fan" necessarily, I certainly don't mind his music. I never once caught any comparisons to Springsteen in the music, and if he happens to present that kind of image and Sony knows it sells, why blame him for it? The album is selling for between $5.99 and $7.99 everywhere I see it - he's likely the one not making much, if anything, on this venture, but Sony sure is. "Everything that is wrong" with music today? Hardly. Look to the Britneys, the Limp Bizkits, the Sugar Rays for everything that is wrong with music today, not someone like Pete Yorn.

#2 — June 2, 2003 @ 17:09PM — mike

Rock musicians are only authentic if they're physically unkempt and have greasy hair teeming with lice. If they puke all other the rock critic during an interview, then they are even more authentic.

Also, it helps to have a serious drug habit and to beat your girlfriend on a regular basis (see Axl Rose). Writing songs without melodies is another helpful sign. Only homos put melodies in their songs.

And if you're not carrying a bottle of whiskey when you stumble onto the stage three hours late, then you are truly a pretty boy wimp who epitomizes everything that's wrong with rock and roll.

#3 — June 2, 2003 @ 17:19PM — Amber [URL]

*Applause

#4 — June 29, 2005 @ 15:21PM — jeff

did kevin canfiled crawl back into the hole he came out of? he's the real hack.

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/5814)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments