The Ultimates

Written by Bill Sherman
Published February 02, 2003
page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5

Our team prevails by chapter's end, changing the monster back into his weedy Banner self (where he's promptly straitjacketed), then hushing up the scientist's involvement in the Hulk rampage. But despite - or perhaps because of - this victory, we don't end Book One on a happy note. In the final chapter, we get a depressing glimpse into the married life of Hank & Janet Pym.

Still sulking over the fact that he got his ass kicked in the Big Green Fight, Hank holds up in his lab. When wife Janet attempts to pull him out to a dinner at Tony Stark's, he snaps back jealously, and things escalate into a full-blown physical fight between the two. The panel where Hank first hauls off and hits his wife is even more dismaying than the scenes where Hulk threatens to rape Betty (if only because we know that the good guys are gonna prevent that appalling act from happening), and are about as far from the original characters as you can get. But does the scene make any sense?

As it plays, the moment works. Millar & Hitch do a decent job building their scene (we're given a hint that this is not the first time the two have come to blows) and even capture such subtleties as the moment where, mid-fight, Janet apologizes for starting a conflict that really is more Hank's fault than hers. The fight also ends on an ambiguous note: Janet being overwhelmed by ants that have attacked her on Hank's command (as he tells her in an ominous full-face close-up, "You shouldn't have made me look small, Jan!"), then a full-page scene of Pym seated in the wreckage of lab, bemoaning what he has done. Very effective.

And yet - and yet . . . for the first time since I started this series, I suddenly find myself growing all fanboyish. A bit that I would've accepted in a newish superhero title like The Authority can't help but feel off when it's built around characters who've been around for ages, even if they are supposed to be the new-&-improved Ultimate versions. It's not like I have any great love for the first Hank Pym. Truth be the told, the original version was a stiff. But I'm even less enamored w./ the idea of making the guy a wife beater. Call me old-fashioned.

In the end, the issue ultimately comes down to this: when does revisionism cross over into shock value contrariness? It's a dividing line that probably varies from reader to reader, but we all recognize when it's been crossed. It's that moment when you suddenly feel a sinking sense of betrayal by the actions of a bunch of featherweight figures on glossy paper.

page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5
Bill Sherman is a mostly harmless pop culture nerd who can either be found at the Pop Culture Gadabout blog or in his capacity as Comics & Graphics Novel review editor at this here site. He once wrote a history of underground comix for a Spanish comics encyclopedia - which he can no longer read since he lost the original manscript and can't read Spanish.
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
The Ultimates
Published: February 02, 2003
Type:
Section: Books
Filed Under: Books: SF
Writer: Bill Sherman
Bill Sherman's BC Writer page
Bill Sherman's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Bill Sherman
Books: SF
All Books Articles
Bill Sherman's personal weblog
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — February 2, 2003 @ 13:31PM — Eric Olsen

I think it's tremendous that we ae seeing such serious consideration of comics here. Any opinions on "American Splendor"? Harvey lives here in Cleveland.

#2 — February 2, 2003 @ 14:18PM — Bill Sherman [URL]

I've long been an American Splendor booster - and I'm heartened by the push that Pekar is receiving due to the movie adaptation's successful opening at Sundance. Yeah, his book deserves Blogcritic consideration . . .

#3 — February 6, 2003 @ 15:46PM — Alex Knapp [URL]

In the comics, the Pyms were a pretty at-odds couple (though not to the point of domestic violence, what with the comics code and all), and the issue after the end of the trade delves more into that.

I think that what's working very well with the Ultimates so far is the notion that it takes more than just superpowers and fighting evil to make you a hero. As the story is progressing, you definitely see some shuffling to that effect. Stark and Cap are definitely heroes. Fury is very ambiguous (and even more so in the other Ultimate lines) as is Thor (anti-globo hero or cult leader?), while Hank Pym and Bruce Banner clearly are clearly not. It's that aspect of the characters that I find interesting, because, face it: much as we admire cops, there are crooked cops out there. And some of them, even though they're crooked, do good things and fight the bad guys. It's a much more realistic take on heroes, and a perfect way to handle the Ultimates since it's an ensemble comic. Solitary comics just can't go that route (well, except maybe Punisher.)

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/2973)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments