The Whack Mentality
Published December 09, 2002
- The always-great character Hesh Rabkin was only in one scene of one episode- he should really get his own episode some time, like Butters did on "South Park."
- And the relationship between Bobby Bacala and Janice came across both as unnecessary and very, very creepy - why put the show's most sympathetic character together with its most unsympathetic?
But regardless, I still recognize that "Sopranos" is still the best drama (if not the best show, period) on television. I would even venture to say that Season 4 was better than Season 3, which lacked memorable episodes (other than the one with the Russian) and seemed at times to revolve around the never-very-interesting character of Jackie, Jr. And don't forget - Jackie (in the final episode) was the one and only regular cast member whacked in Season 3, although numerous others (Livia Soprano, Bobby Bacala, Sr., and Gigi Cestone) died of natural causes, or of other non-whack-related illness. So it's not like there was some mythical golden age in which major characters got whacked perpetually.
What Season 3 did have was a disturbingly large amount of violence against women, including the beating to death of a stripper and the brutal rape of Dr. Melfi. Is this what all those fans are so nostalgic for? Then again, maybe that's what got them hooked on the show in the first place...
- The Whack Mentality
- Published: December 09, 2002
- Type:
- Section: Video
- Filed Under: Video: Drama, Video: Television
- Writer: Stephen Silver
- Stephen Silver's BC Writer page
- Stephen Silver's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us
Comments
Good review. I'll have the opposing view posted later tonight as I am one of the disappointed fans, but not for a lack of 'whacking.' It's deeper than that.






Super thoughtful and important review - thanks! Much to my dismay I missed this season due to scheduling and whatnot so I am in no position to comment on content, but I also picked up on the negative comments, including SNL last Saturday (calling it "boring"). Your comments on this sound very apt, but it could also just be backlash - I have been amazed at the universal praise until now, so maybe it was inevitable. Will have to see this season on DVD I guess. Thanks again.