Finisterre, or The End Of The Earth

Written by Paul Frankenstein
Published November 19, 2002
page 1 | 2

The Saint enlists the services of the English rapper Wildflower on the track "Soft Like Me", a paean to the positive powers of femininity with a sunny, bouncy chorus that you can almost imagine Karen Carpenter singing. The genius of this song is how it places praise for the qualities of emotional openness and tenderness in the context of rap — an American genre noted for brutish masculinity and misogyny. I would use the word "subvert" here, but I've been informed that only licensed Academics can use it without irony.

"Stop and Think It Over" is a ballad that would, in most hands, turn irredeemably syrupy; the regret in Cracknell's breathy voice and the musically unresolved ending keeps the track from toppling over entirely into mush.

"Shower Scene" is another house (that is the right word to use, right?) anthem with utterly obtuse lyrical content ("in the rain/in the fall/in the mud/in the hall/in the rain/in the fog/in the shice/call my name" are pretty much all the lyrics of the four-and-a-half-minute song); interpretation of what that actually means is fairly open.

Like all clever pop bands, Saint Etienne has often been accused of being too self-referential; they do nothing to refute this charge on Finisterre. The track "The Way We Live Now" is clearly a reference to "The Way We Used To Live", a nine-minute single off of Sound of Water; the band name-checks one of their own songs in "B92," a satiric take on the music industry.

The one thing from previous Saint Etienne albums that rabid fans might miss is the constant sense of Ameriphilia; there are, as far as I can tell, virtually no explicitly American references on the album (which is rather unusual for a band that has produced songs titled "Erica America", "The Boy Scouts of America", "I Buy American Records", and "Zipcode", among others). The closest they come is in "Finisterre", the last track on the CD. Sarah Churchill (any relation to the PM? I don't know) intones "I believe in Donovan over Dylan, a laugh over cynicism" during a memerizing interior monologue, a retreat into the landscape of the mind. The final chorus — "Finisterre, to tear it down and start again" — is maybe a message, perhaps a manifesto, and, possibly, a hint for those wondering what the band is trying to do.

page 1 | 2
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Buy from Amazon.com
Finisterre Finisterre
Saint Etienne
Music,
Tiger Bay Tiger Bay
Saint Etienne
Music,
Good Humor Good Humor
Saint Etienne
Music,
So Tough So Tough
Saint Etienne
Music,
Foxbase Alpha Foxbase Alpha
Saint Etienne
Music,

Finisterre, or The End Of The Earth
Published: November 19, 2002
Type:
Section: Music
Filed Under: Music: Alternative Rock, Music: Pop
Writer: Paul Frankenstein
Paul Frankenstein's BC Writer page
Paul Frankenstein's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Paul Frankenstein
Music: Alternative Rock
Music: Pop
All Music Articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — November 19, 2002 @ 19:36PM — Eric Olsen

I like SE but I used to love them - their best and freshest work was at the beginning. I do like the new one better than any for a while however. Very nice review.

#2 — November 19, 2002 @ 19:47PM — Paul Frankenstein [URL]

Yeah, their first three albums are really extraordinary. Of course, then you run into the "what next?" problem: once you've made something as good as Tiger Bay, what next?

#3 — November 21, 2002 @ 20:23PM — fred

I have found that tracking down their Japanese fanclub compilations "Continental" and "Fairy tales of" are well worth the trouble (and cost). They usually include rare b-sides and other hard to find stuff.
SE have not just been a great group to get remixes of, but have usually been ahead of the curb in finding people to remix for them. From early Chemical Brothers, David Holmes, and Aphex Twin remixes, to having Rick Smith from Underworld helping them produce several songs on Tiger Bay.
A lot of their musical explorations also can be seen in the side projects they have worked on. Sarah has put a decent solo album (not up to SE level, but decent none-the-less). Bob and Pete have started several record labels in the past. I interviewed Bob once for a zine (around Good Humour) and he mentioned a fascination with J-pop bands.


Fred

#4 — November 21, 2002 @ 21:21PM — Eric Olsen

Very interesting Fred, thanks.

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/1932)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments