Thursday, Jonah's onelinedrawing, From Autumn To Ashes, Planes Mistaken For Stars

Written by Craig Kleemann
Published November 02, 2002
page 1 | 2

I've decided that I'm not cool at all because I never listened to onelinedrawing before. I kept on hearing how great Jonah was, and how great Far was when he was in it, but never really got around to getting into him. I had only heard continuously good things, and they all happened to be true. Jonah got onstage with an electric guitar plugged into a 6 inch wide fender mini amplifier, and a drum machine/sampler in the form of R2-D2. Pretension went out the window. For the next half hour, I witnessed perhaps the most sincere, vital one man show I've ever seen. If irony is dead, Jonah killed it. The songs are great on their own, and require no real explanation, They are simple vocal-driven anthems about every day topics presented in a very real manner by a guy that you could meet and subsequently hire as your babysitter. His banter with the crowd kept a smile on every face, as did his mid-song breaks. It just seemed like he was too excited about what he has to say to wait for a chance to speak between songs. He joyously thanked the crowd for singing along, but for doing so quietly enough that others could hear. He put aside what he wanted to play to play a set of almost all requests. I could talk for days about Jonah, but the most telling comment I could make is that his pants weren't tight, and he still rocked. If Jonah ever comes to your town, don't miss him. Brave the opening bands to witness the spectacle, you won't be disappointed.

Next up were the darlings of radio DJs who think they are into underground music. This isn't meant as anything bad against Thursday, it's just that their especially catchy brand of melodic hardcore brought in a lot of fans that wouldn't be at the shows otherwise. In tight pants and sporting a new keyboard player (not sure how long he's been in the band), Thursday opened with "Paris in Flames," followed by the single "Understanding in a Car Crash." The crowd seemed to be enjoying it immensely, and the band was definitely tight, but something just seemed a little off for me. Perhaps it was the hand motions that Geoff accompanied the songs with. Perhaps it was the somewhat canned staged presence by the band. Maybe the band's just been on tour for too long. In any case, the show just lacked the sincerity that I had expected. The music lacked the urgency that exists on the recording (Full Collapse, on Victory Records), and the band seemed to simply be pantomiming itself. The notes were perfect, but I couldn't really believe that they were feeling any of it, there was a lack of the catharsis I expected. They were great, don't get me wrong, but maybe they would have been better if they hadn't been touring nonstop for the last year. I would still recommend everybody to go see Thursday, maybe I just caught them on an off night, but for this one show, they were outshone by a man with a ratty electric guitar and an R2-D2.

page 1 | 2
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Buy from Amazon.com
Fuck With Fire Fuck With Fire
Planes Mistaken for Stars
Music,
Planes Mistaken for Stars Planes Mistaken for Stars
Planes Mistaken for Stars
Music,
Five Stories Falling Five Stories Falling
Thursday
Music,
Always New: Juldec00 Always New: Juldec00
Jonah's Onelinedrawing
Music,
Full Collapse Full Collapse
Thursday
Music,
Knife in the Marathon Knife in the Marathon
Planes Mistaken for Stars
Music,
Sketchy EP #1 Sketchy EP #1
Jonah's Onelinedrawing
Music,
Too Bad You're Beautiful Too Bad You're Beautiful
From Autumn to Ashes
Music,

Thursday, Jonah's onelinedrawing, From Autumn To Ashes, Planes Mistaken For Stars
Published: November 02, 2002
Type:
Section: Music
Filed Under: Music: Alternative Rock, Music: Rock
Writer: Craig Kleemann
Craig Kleemann's BC Writer page
Craig Kleemann's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Craig Kleemann
Music: Alternative Rock
Music: Rock
All Music Articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — November 2, 2002 @ 19:00PM — Eric Olsen

Great job Craig, sounds like a smoking hot show. I secretly love emo - Thursday is one of my favorite recent bands, didn't know the others until now.

#2 — October 28, 2004 @ 21:28PM — Shelly

I have been trying to figure out who the female vocalist is with FATA. I have had NO luck at all. She sings several songs. Favorite most of all is Short Stories With Tragic Endings. I'm stumped. Have any ideas?

#3 — September 27, 2005 @ 01:51AM — aaron

her name is melanie wills, shes the singer of a band called 'one true thing' im not sure if they are around anymore.

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/1640)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments