Narcissism is what Eminem has to show

Written by Walter Enderby
Published September 25, 2002

I'll grant that Eminem has talent as a rapper. Musically, "The Eminem Show" is brilliant. Lyrically, Eminem may be able to sling rhymes with a creative verve that is rare in any songwriter. I always appreciate originality and abhor triteness. On these counts, I tip my hat to Slim Shady.


But that is as far as I can go in praising this decrepit and mentally unbalanced person. The genius of a musician does not excuse record companies from inflicting this garbage on society. "The Eminem Show" is full of violence, especially violence against women, and demonstrates not an ounce of empathy for any other soul on the planet. Marshall Mathers may very well be the biggest narcissist to ever hit the big time.


Consider "Hallie's Song," a lyric purportedly dedicated to his daughter, but full of venom, in which he pretty much places himself at the center of the universe.


This boulder on my shoulder gets heavy and harder to hold
And this load is like the weight of the world
And I think my neck is breaking should I just give up,
Or try to live up to these expectations?


The chief object of Eminem's rage in "Hallie's Song" is Hallie's mother. Eminem's enemy list, however, would make Nixon jealous. His persecutors include his mother, father, parents of his fans, his fans, lawyers, cops, any other women he's ever met, other entertainers, critics, journalists ... the list seems endless.


The only blameless person seems to be Eminem himself.


Narcissism is a noxious mental disease that leads people to grandiose delusions. Narcissism must be fed. It can be fed by fame and adoration, or it can be fed by violence and notoriety. Eminem has a love-hate relationship with fame, but digs the hell out of violence. Gun shots and talk of whacking some bitch or a record executive or two are the subplot to the entire show.


But not to worry, Eminem tells us. This is just rap. He's just an entertainer. He's not trying to inspire imitators.


As he raps in another narcissistic tale, "Without Me:"


They say music can alter moods and talk to you
But can it load a gun for you and cock it too?


In other words, Eminem doesn't kill people. People kill people. If a fan buys a gun, shoots somebody, only the fan is to blame. We are each masters of our own fate.


Of course, Eminem doesn't hold himself to this standard. For example, Mathers is blameless when it comes to violence against the mother of his child:


I got a wife that's determined to make my life livin hell
But I handle it well, given the circumstances I'm dealt
So many chances, man, it's too bad, coulda had someone else
But the years that I've wasted are nothing to the tears that I've tasted
So here's what im facin:
3 felonies, 6 years of probation


If you still don't believe that Eminem has a serious narcissistic complex, compare the following passage from a Web site on narcissism with the lyric I quote below:


The second mechanism that the narcissist employs is the active pursuit of "Narcissistic Supply". The Narcissist actively seeks to furnish himself with an endless supply of admiration, adulation, affirmation and attention. ... If fame cannot be had — infamy and notoriety will do.


And from "Hallie's Song"


When I was little I knew I would blow up
And sell a mil or grow up to be a tiller
Go nuts and be a killer


Another aspect of narcissism is a sense of omnipotence. The following lyrics are from "My Daddy's Gone Crazy."


There's no mountain i can't climb
There's no tower too high,
No plane that i can't learn how to fly


Besides being a narcissist of unprecedented proportions, Eminem is just a plain old whiner. He doesn't like fame and life is pretty miserable. He sums it up best on "Say Goodbye to Hollywood."


But no one ever puts a grasp on the fact i've sacrificed everything I have
I never dreamt i'd get to the level that i'm at, this is whack
This is more than I ever could of asked
everywhere I go, a hat, a sweater hood, or mask
What about math, how come I wasn't ever good at that
It's like the boy in the bubble, who never could adapt, i'm trapped
If I could go back, I never woulda rapped


Now fans of Eminem might object that I'm being a little harsh. After all, "he's just an entertainer; who are you to psychoanalyze him?" I can imagine Eminem himself saying the same thing. In fact, Eminem makes the point more than once that he's just jivin' with us. He's havin' fun. At the same time, however,he admits, "a lot of truth is said in jest."


If Eminem thinks he's givin' us some truth, maybe we should take him a little more seriously.


Whenever Eminem is criticized, I hear his defenders say, "Look, it's up to the parents to police their kids."


It's a nice sounding platitude, but it's a straw man. No one who has ever been a parent of a pre-teen or teen would ever seriously spout such nonsense. If you are a parent who believes a guy like Eminem shouldn't be filling a kid's ears with filth, good luck trying to keep it away from your children. It's impossible, because there's always at least one kid on the block who already owns the CD. And when your kid secretly buys it to keep up with the peer pressure, there's hell to pay when you confiscate it.


Parents should rightly be concerned about Eminem. He makes narcissism sound cool, even normal. And narcissism is a seductive mental disorder. Some amount of narcissism is a natural stage for many teen boys. Fortunately, most boys grow into men and learn the value of empathy. They learn because traditionally there has been little in society, even in popular culture, that promoted narcissism as an admirable trait. My concern is that Eminem changes that equation.


It's telling that even Marshall Mathers understands that his music is potentially destructive. At the end of "My Daddy's Gone Crazy," he raps, "i wouldn't let hailie listen to me neither."


I'm 100 percent behind free speech, and in no regard am I suggesting that Eminem should be banned. But I also believe in corporate responsibility. As good as Eminem is musically, as talented as he is as a rapper, there is a good chance that he would be just another small-label windbag if he didn't get corporate promotion. It is next to impossible these days to become a major star without a record boss stoking the fires of fame. I'm not asking the government to do anything about Eminem and his ilk. I'm asking record companies to realize that they have a responsibility to a civil society. They have a responsibility to future generations. They have a responsibility to look beyond the bottom line.

page 1 | 2
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Narcissism is what Eminem has to show
Published: September 25, 2002
Type:
Section: Music: Rap
Writer: Walter Enderby
Walter Enderby's BC Writer page
Walter Enderby's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Walter Enderby
All Music: Rap Articles
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — August 15, 2003 @ 11:28AM — heijens

man you are full off crap, haven't you anything else to do with your free time then start bullshitting about other poeple???
"This boulder on my shoulder gets heavy and harder to hold
And this load is like the weight of the world
And I think my neck is breaking should I just give up,
Or try to live up to these expectations?"
Don't you ever feel like it's to much, like you can't handle some things in your life, I do. He has millions of eyes on him, a lot of people would like to see him failing and there are big expectations, each record has to be great and better as the previous.
"There's no mountain i can't climb
There's no tower too high,
No plane that i can't learn how to fly"
this lyric is good because it makes me feel very confedent of myself, I think a lot of kinds feel that way, it's a big support in my life. So if you don't feel or understand his music don't start bullshitting about him.

#2 — August 15, 2003 @ 12:27PM — Eric Olsen

That's cool, but remember spelling counts

#3 — August 15, 2003 @ 15:54PM — Al Barger [URL]

Howard, I appreciate your concern. I've gotten to hear my 8 and 13 year old nieces singing Eminem in harmony. Even his less provocative material sounds pretty bad to me in that context.

On the other hand, your concerns may not be quite so pressing. For one thing, way the biggest influence in a child's development is going to be his home life, not movies and records.

Also, you may be underestimating the ability of children to grasp the basic idea of artistic detachment. Even most 10 year olds would grasp that the songs are fiction, and that you wouldn't really want to be Slim Shady. Indeed, Marshall Mathers ain't Eminem, let alone Slim Shady. You might be surprised how much of this the young audience picks up.

#4 — April 18, 2005 @ 12:39PM — felix

what are you talking about???! Eminem,a narcissistic? God damn if it wasn't for him, so many kids would lack confidence and self-esteem. Don't you undrestand that self-respect and pride are very different from narcissism? Maaaan, let us feel good about ourselves for christ'sake.

PRIDE:CONFIDENCE:CONVICTION:SELF-RESPECT

#5 — May 22, 2006 @ 21:56PM — tj

you don't understand what you are talking about

#6 — September 9, 2006 @ 02:19AM — A Psych Grad Student

The tentative consideration of a possible diagnosis of Narcisstic Personality Disorder is a reasonable conclusion. I would also add that there are additional Histrionic and Depressive tendencies shown in this artist's lyrics and behaviors.

I was curious as to what my brother was listening to before rejecting it outright, so I listened to these songs. Musically they are extremely catchy. Lyrically, your points are dead-on. Yes, his public persona is narcissistic and probably his private persona is largely narcissistic as well.

My brother is coping with an abusive mother too so perhaps he identifies with this music. However, obviously, I am coping with the same mother, and I started down the same angry, self-defensive path, but after much learning experiences, I know that letting our narcisstic tendencies develop out of proportion to our empathy, humility, and peace of mind, is a recipe for disaster, and this music therefore is more of a negative and pain-causing factor on humanity than a blessing.

To his faithful-to-death-and-beyond fans, what feels like "self-esteem" now (and feels good, or at least, feels better than what you were feeling before), at some point you may notice seems inflated and unfulfilling long-term, because it is only an oversized *image* of self-esteem covering up your still-bruised self-acceptance, it's not the real thing.

Only when you let yourself be humble, acknowledge your flaws and pain, but know too that you have just as much right to acceptance and love and respect as anyone else -- The Right To Be Human, can you develop real, satisfying self-esteem and the peace of mind to build a world for yourself that will bring you joy.

#7 — August 8, 2007 @ 11:30AM — Anonymous

That explains everything, my ex-husband listened to Eminem all the time. He and his mother were both disturbing, and then there's my father and stepmom. They're raising little Narks, I know this because they treat everyone who isn't them like a slave or enemy. I'm just glad I know this and I'm happier without them. For people asking if they should try harder, just forget it, they have a god complex. Run for your life, you won't be judged for it except by Narks.

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/802)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!