Songs for the Deaf - QOTSA

Written by Phillip Winn
Published August 26, 2002
page 1 | 2 | 3

At this point I think any listener will have to acknowledge the first-rate drumming on this album. Dave Grohl is a wizard with a drum kit, and here he plays a little harder, and maybe just a little better, than I've ever heard him play for Nirvana or Foo Fighters. QOTSA is mostly synonymous with power chords, yes, but even those who don't appreciate the guitar-playing skill involved will surely recognize Grohl's mastery of his instrument.

The rest of the album mostly continues the trend of hard-rock guitars with a distinctive melody. A Song for the Dead and The Sky Is Falling act almost as a matched pair, and the vocal harmonies found in both (but especially in The Sky Is Falling) are - dare I say it? - almost Beatlesque. It's a shame when the songs end and the little fake radio bits come on again.

Six Shooter is a dreadful bit of screaming. I am sorry that it was included on the album, as it marks 80 seconds or so of music worth skipping. Fortunately, Hanging Tree is solid.

Go With The Flow is one of the standout tracks of the album, at least for me. Perhaps it just reminds me quite a bit of Foo Fighters, but I've listened to this track twice as much as most of the rest of the album. That's probably one reason why I'm so unhappy about the little radio bits - I have to listen to an especially annoying one at the end of this song each and every time.

If Go With The Flow sets the pace for harmony, Gonna Leave You ups the ante. While the lyrics are more repetitive than the last track, the vocals are smooth, and nicely balance out the guitar track. Do It Again seems to be a bid for Arena-rock status, and the nod to Gary Glitter's Rock and Roll Part One in the beginning will probably get them some play during sports events.

I've commented on nearly every song, but that's because I've been really excited about most of them. Even the odd "hidden" Mosquito Song is strangely appealing. Dropping the rock facade completely, QOTSA show their tender side and reveal that they are really a piano and violin band at heart. While the style for this song is radically different from the rest, it manages to make itself at home thanks to repeated vocal and harmony themes that have become familiar from the rest of the album.

I normally try to listen to an album at least a dozen times before I review it. That gives me a chance to grow to like some songs that initially didn't sit well with me, as well as to grow annoyed at things that didn't bother me very much the first couple of times through. In order to get the review out prior to the album's release, I've compressed the usual schedule and I've only listened the the album a few times. It's enough to already grow extremely annoyed at the radio tidbits between the songs (obviously), but I've noticed already that all of the songs (except Six Shooter) just sound better the more I hear them.

page 1 | 2 | 3
Phillip Winn is the Chief Geek for BC Magazine, and a blogger since 1995. He can currently be found and followed on Twitter.
Keep reading for information and comments on this article, and add some feedback of your own!
Songs for the Deaf - QOTSA
Published: August 26, 2002
Type:
Section: Music
Filed Under: Music: Alternative Rock, Music: Hard Rock, Music: Rock
Writer: Phillip Winn
Phillip Winn's BC Writer page
Phillip Winn's personal site
Spread the Word
Like this article?
Email this
Submit to del.icio.us Save to del.icio.us
RSS Feeds
All RSS Feeds (240+)
Comments on this article
BC articles by Phillip Winn
Music: Alternative Rock
Music: Hard Rock
Music: Rock
All Music Articles
Phillip Winn's personal weblog
All BC articles
All BC Comments

Comments

#1 — August 26, 2002 @ 16:06PM — Steve Rhodes [URL]


They are doing an in-store at Virgin in San Francisco Monday night at 11 pm.

#2 — August 27, 2002 @ 10:30AM — John Fogde [URL]

The DVD features live versions of five tracks. The first three (Monsters in the Parasol, No One Knows, and The Lost Art of Keeping a Secret) were recorded at the Troubador this year and the last two (Quick and to the Pointless and Ode to Clarissa) were recorded in 2000 at Vintage Vinyl.
The highlight of the DVD is seeing Dave Grohl go nuts on the drums during No One Knows. It's an awesome song and their performance is pretty cool as well.

#3 — August 30, 2002 @ 08:28AM — Phillip Winn [URL]

I did finally sit down and spend some time with it. There is also a ton of footage between the songs, recorded at the studio, backstage, and just goofing around. It's pretty interesting, actually, for the glimpse it gives into the recording process. Mostly however, it's just what you'd expect if you gave anybody a digicam and let him do whatever he wanted.

And yes, Grohl is a madman on the drums in that song, which has incidentally become my favorite song on the album. I just wish I new exactly what was in his mouth!

#4 — August 31, 2002 @ 04:58AM — Rob [URL]

According to Homme it's all about the drive from la to joshua tree. Flipping through channels on the radio and coming across what QOTSA's vision of the radio should be.. A 'concept' record if it could be as under-stated as that. These guys rock.

And isn't Grohl somewhat notorious for chewing gum while banging drums? Betcha that's what that is in the vid..

#5 — September 4, 2002 @ 14:20PM — Chris Puzak [URL]

This was better than I expected, but I'm a little disappointed that they haven't been able to equal their work in Kyuss.

#6 — October 18, 2005 @ 01:03AM — Cam

I read somethin JOsh Homme said First it giveth is about the creative then destructive effect of drugs man.

#7 — October 18, 2005 @ 09:05AM — Phillip Winn [URL]

Yes, I heard that after writing this review as well. With that in mind, the lyrics make a little more sense. :-)

Want comments emailed to you? No spam, promise! Address:

Add your comment, speak your mind

(Or ping: http://blogcritics.org/mt/tb/234)

Personal attacks are not allowed. Please read our comment policy.





Remember Name/URL?

Please preview your comment!

Fresh
Articles
Fresh
Comments