Today on Blogcritics
Home » Americans Flock to India for Treatment

Americans Flock to India for Treatment

Please Share...Print this pageTweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

A bit of a counter-intuitive thought and process here, but Americans in need of surgery are headed to India for shorter waits and costs about 75 percent less than the amount someone could fork over in America.

People do get great medical help in this country, though it is horribly expensive for even the most minor of surgeries. Doctors I’ve talked to blame malpractice and insurance companies but they pick on malpractice because they figure convincing legislators that it is bad for lawyers to make money is easier than convincing them insurance companies charge through the roof because they can.

Talk about your Hobson’s Choice.

Robert Walter Beeney was unable to walk due to a stiff hip when he landed in India Jan 24. Twenty days later, he not only recovered after a rare hip replacement surgery at Apollo Hospital here but also visited the famous Taj Mahal in Agra after that.

The 64-year-old real estate consultant from San Francisco underwent successful surface replacement surgery using the anatomic surface replacement (ASR) hip system Jan 27, reportedly becoming the first US national to come to India for the treatment.

…A team of doctors, led by orthopaedic surgeon Vijay Bose, carried out the procedure for Beeney. Jayaramchander Pingle, a member of the medical team, told a news conference Tuesday that while in the conventional hip replacement surgery the total hip was replaced in the new system the patient’s original head and neck of femur were preserved and only their surface is replaced with metal on metal articulation.

With the use of very advanced metallurgy in this device, the wear and tear is reduced to a fraction in the artificial joint as opposed to the conventional total hip replacement.

Another advantage of the latest procedure is that in the event of any problem that may occur in the long term, the conventional total hip replacement can be done at a later stage.

Beeney, who came to know about the procedure in India through the Internet, said that since this was not yet cleared by the US Food and Drug Administration, he decided to come here.

“This is despite the fact that the device that is fixed in the hip is made in the US,” he said.

Powered by

About temple

Always been a writer, always maintained an interest in politics, how people communicate and fantasy worlds within photography and books. Previously wrote for Blogcritics back in 2005 and interested in exploring the issues and topics I'm interested - the changing landscape of entertainment. all from the POV of a creator first, consumer, second.
  • Aaman

    Indian hospitals are among the best – a select few of them. This is good – if you can get the service, you will go where it is cheapest. That will also have the effect of driving costs down in the US, IMHO

    Check your headline, Temple – America’s ??

  • Temple Stark

    Read it as “The country’s flock to …. ”

    Drive down the costs. Yes. I’ve stayed away from getting medical, dental, visual help because of the cost. And I’m pretty damn healthy but isn’t that the point of preventative health care (not that this piece is about preventative but …

  • Eric Berlin

    Wow, this is truly an era of global competition. I think Aaman’s right — competition can only help to reform the US health care system.

    It’s obvious that our government won’t bring down costs, so perhaps India and other nations will.

  • alienboy

    why don’t you get Bush to cancel all medical treatment in the usa? let’s just outsource the whole deal to India. maybe they vcan sort ouot your social security system too, lol

  • Temple Stark

    Aaman I should have interviewed you. You’ve probably recieved healthcare in both places, though hopefully major surgery in neither.

    India may be the country with the widest extremes. And with a country so large, with so many languages, being so central to everything, well, they have a pretty good future ahead of them don’t they.

  • Eric Berlin

    It certainly seems like the Future (capital F) is headed in the direction of Asia. Was listening to NPR/BBC last night — interviews with Chinese scientists, professors, and people familiar with the research scene in Asia. Upshot is that great strides are being made, and if more reforms are made to modernize / free up more resources and creative potential, “the future’s wide open,” as Tom Petty sang.

  • Dave Nalle

    How on earth do the email spammers think they’ll get anywhere posting the same scam to a blog?


  • Chicago Geek

    I too prefer getting my dental done in India in each trip I make there. In last trip, I spent $20 for 3 tooth filling and $180 for minor nose operation for better air passage to avoid congestion.



    Americans flock to India for Shoulder and Knee surgery. James Spark, Dave Hurd, Karthick, and many more Americans have undergone shoulder, Knee and limb surgery by Chennai’s Knee & Shoulder specialist. “Services were of the same standard with a personalised touch” says Mr.Dave Hurd from North Carolina who underwent key hole shoulder surgery for a torn rotator cuff of twenty years duration.
    Visit for more information on prices of surgery.

  • joint replacement

    Same is happening here in the UK, British are flying to Tunisia, Belgium and many other countries, looking for affodable surgical and medical healthcare. Joint replacement waiting list is too long and people can not really put up with the pain for months

  • Dr. Frank Pedlow

    I agree with Dave. Where do these spammers expect to get wit that?