Today on Blogcritics
Home » Film » American Idol: Season 8 Finale: Chaotic and Flat!

American Idol: Season 8 Finale: Chaotic and Flat!

Please Share...Tweet about this on Twitter0Share on Facebook0Share on Google+0Share on LinkedIn0Pin on Pinterest0Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUpon0Share on Reddit0Email this to someone

What started out as bonding time with my 12-year-old daughter (who can sing) slowly progressed to a show that I looked forward to watching two times a week – I became a fan of American Idol, well until the finale?

First I must disclose that I’ve never been a fan of “reality shows” (not since being a contestant on one of the first, American Gladiators). I couldn't tell you anything about Survivor, The Apprentice, or The Biggest Loser, other than their titles. However, last year, I watched my first American Idol (Season 7) where the finale included David Cook and David Archuleta (my favorite), and enjoyed it very much.

This season had the normal contestant drama, quirkiness, and lack of talent, coupled with the few extraordinary contenders. But there were some surprises, starting with a new judge, Kara DioGuardi. Where did she come from? Does she talk too much?

Paula Abdul is very sweet, seems to like all of the contestants, and thank goodness is not long-winded. The other surprise was when she took the stage and performed her new song, “I’m Just Here for the Music”! While Paula proved she can still dance and looks awesome for her age (or any age for that matter), did she lip-sync?

Randy Jackson is always cool, polite and is a remarkable judge of talent, however, I prefer Simon Cowell’s no-nonsense style of evaluating the performances. In the music business, if you can’t sing you should know, and hopefully before you try-out for American Idol.

The best part of American Idol this year (other than how cute Ryan Seacrest is) were actually the contestants themselves, starting with the final ten. The top five were truly gifted vocalists and performers: Matt Giraud, Allison Iraheta, (my second favorite), Danny Gokey, Kris Allen, and Adam Lambert.

The final showdown was set for two of the best: Kris Allen, the dark horse from Arkansas, is very humble and stood out from the crowd because of his diversity (voice, guitar, and piano). Adam Lambert, the flash from California, who reminds me of Elvis and Alice Cooper combined, has a “unique voice and style,” is very charming and shined with his “rock star” quality from day one!

The finale was chaotic and flat. There were only a few performances that were worth watching: Adam with Kiss (I am no Kiss fan), Allison and Cyndi Lauper (no fan either), and Danny Gokey with Lionel Richie. I especially liked the performance of Kris and Adam with Queen ("We are the Champions"), but why did they keep bringing the final thirteen into every performance?

Did Rod Stewart trip on stage? How could Fergie walk, let alone dance, in that outfit? Where was the comic relief? Hardly from Kara, Katrina, and Tatiana. Where are Jack Black, Ben Stiller, and Robert Downey Jr. when you need them? And why did America, with close to 100 million votes, choose Kris Allen over Adam Lambert as Season 8’s American Idol?

I was very impressed with the finale of Season 7 even though my guy, David Archuleta, didn’t win, so why did Season 8’s finale leave me indifferent? Am I still an American Idol fan? Not today. Today I’m just a critic. But there is always next year.

Powered by

About Christine Lakatos

  • J. reforma

    I must agree with you that this Season finale between Adam and Kris left me wondering… I’m unconvinced… Maybe they should change rules in voting…

  • http://pwinn.tumblr.com/ Phillip Winn

    My and I observed that this year’s finale seemed less exciting than last year’s. I’m not sure how much of that had to do with who won, though. We both were rooting for David Cook, who won, and I was rooting for Adam Lambert, who lost, while my wife was rooting for Danny Gokey, who came in third.

    Still, it seemed *slightly* more subdued overall this year.

  • Maddy Pumilia

    I thought it was a great finale. Of course, I was a Kris fan. The highlight for me was Kris Allen with Keith Urban. But that’s probably because I love country music.

    I loved Archuletta last year. I interviewed him last year at this AIDS charity event. Such a sweet guy. I just wanted to hug him.

    :)

    Maddy

  • http://blogcritics.org/writers/christine-lakatos-/ Christine Lakatos

    Thanks for commenting! Kris, Adam, David C., and David A. will all be successful.

  • dee

    i loved Adam/Kiss and the number with Queen-
    i thought allison and cindi were great together….
    the result? disappointing.
    afterwards i felt as tho i had been manipulated. i mean every year the underdog wins? doesn’t matter how bad an underdog all season long? too coincidental for me- it’s rigged. and obviously so.